Comodohacker claims he can exploit Windows Update

Microsoft again contends that code signing prevents malware installation via its update service

The hacker who calls himself "Comodohacker" said this week that he could have used digital certificates stolen from a Dutch firm to issue fake updates to Windows PCs.

If Comodohacker's assertion is accurate, he would have been able to push malware to Windows machines via the operating system's Windows Update service.

[ InfoWorld's Roger Grimes says of the certificate hacks: PKI didn't fail us, humans did. | Also on InfoWorld: Microsoft patches SSL security threat. | Learn how to greatly reduce the threat of malicious attacks with InfoWorld's Insider Threat Deep Dive PDF special report. ]

Microsoft said that was impossible.

Comodohacker, who claims to be a 21-year-old Iranian, has taken credit for several attacks against certificate authorities, or CAs, the organizations and companies authorized to issue SSL (secure socket layer) certificates. In two of those attacks -- of Comodo in March and more recently of DigiNotar -- certificates were fraudulently generated.

Among the 531 certificates stolen in the hack of Dutch-based DigiNotar were several that could be used to impersonate Microsoft's update services.

Comodohacker said he could exploit those certificates.

"I'm able to issue Windows update[s]," Comodohacker claimed in one of several statements he has posted this week on Pastebin. "Microsoft's statement about Windows Update and that I can't issue such update is totally false!"

Last weekend, Microsoft said that the certificates stolen from DigiNotar weren't enough to deliver actual updates.

"Attackers are not able to leverage a fraudulent Windows Update certificate to install malware via the Windows Update servers," said Jonathan Ness, principal development security lead with the Microsoft Security Response Center (MSRC), in a blog post last Sunday. "The Windows Update client will only install binary payloads signed by the actual Microsoft root certificate, which is issued and secured by Microsoft."

Ness also said that even if a hacker was equipped with a fake certificate, "Windows Update itself is not at risk."

When asked Thursday to comment on Comodohacker's claims, Microsoft would only refer to Ness' earlier remarks.

Comodohacker, however, bragged that, he had "already reversed ENTIRE windows update protocol" and could hijack the service. "I can issue updates via windows update! You see? I'm so smart, sharp, dangerous, powerful, etc.," he claimed.

Hackers would now need a different certificate to imitate Windows Update: The certificates pinched from DigiNotar have been revoked and Microsoft has blocked their use within Windows with an update that shipped Tuesday.

Gregg Keizer covers Microsoft, security issues, Apple, Web browsers and general technology breaking news for Computerworld. Follow Gregg on Twitter at @gkeizer or subscribe to Gregg's RSS feed. His email address is

Read more about Cybercrime and Hacking in Computerworld's Cybercrime and Hacking Topic Center.

This story, "Comodohacker claims he can exploit Windows Update" was originally published by Computerworld.

Copyright © 2011 IDG Communications, Inc.

InfoWorld Technology of the Year Awards 2023. Now open for entries!