Thoughts about the economics of offshoring

Dear Bob ...Not really an Advice Line issue, but I'd appreciate your thoughts:Society is learning about economics and outsourcing. Lose high paying jobs, lose tax revenue, etc. The experiment continues and a few profit at the expense of the many. Of course, China is doing well right now, but at what cost?I remember from an analysis of why Asian-American communities succeed, and African-American communities stay

Follow @ITCatalysts

Dear Bob ...

Not really an Advice Line issue, but I'd appreciate your thoughts:

Society is learning about economics and outsourcing. Lose high paying jobs, lose tax revenue, etc. The experiment continues and a few profit at the expense of the many. Of course, China is doing well right now, but at what cost?

I remember from an analysis of why Asian-American communities succeed, and African-American communities stay mired in poverty is that it's because 9 out of 10 dollars spent in the Asian-American community stay within it, while 1 out of every 10 dollars spent in the African-American community stay within it. If such economics scale, then offshoring jobs and factories will not succeed in generating wealth for many but will have the opposite result.

What goods and services will be left? Half the graduates in my department were mainland Chinese. We drained the best minds from around the globe and only the top 10% could get funding as research scientists, and those were the ones without jobs waiting for them in China.

We are now offshoring computer programming and certain other highly skilled professions. Most of our manufacturing jobs that aren't defense related are offshore. With computer hardware,  software, textile, shipbuilding, steel, and other industries offshore, what goods can we provide China to balance the trade imbalance except maybe aerospace?

Loral is no more because they sold defense aerospace secrets to China which will improve their ICBMs. That's about the only thing they want from us now, and Russia gives them better deals if not always expertise. With more of our money going offshore and higher paying jobs migrating offshore to be replaced by lower wage jobs, I can't see any good coming from it. Our cities and states lose tax revenue and a vicious cycle ensues.

Texas only builds tollways now. That's the only way local and some state roads get built or maintained and revenue generated. It used to not be that way 20 years ago. The schools hold fund raisers to obtain funding for public school activities and projects.

College tuition has skyrocketed in Texas in spite of a huge oil funded multibillion dollar endowment. The state pays less and less for public education every year even though the endowments can only pay half the costs.

Maybe it's me, though. I don't always remember being so disillusioned and cynical. But I have to worry when oilmen start buying up water rights throughout the state.

- Concerned

Dear Concerned ...

Whew! Okay, if everyone agrees that I'm just another citizen with no pretensions to specific expertise on any of the subjects you raised, here are some thoughts: