November 10, 2008

Test Center benchmarks: Windows 7 unmasked

Measured by runtime specs and performance benchmarks, Windows 7 M3 looks like Vista, and it runs like Vista. Welcome to Windows Vista R2!

It's here! After months of speculation, Windows 7 was finally unveiled last month at Microsoft's Professional Developers Conference (PDC). Through a series of well-orchestrated keynote presentations and supporting breakout sessions, Microsoft walked conference attendees through the highlights of its new desktop OS: better performance, an improved user experience, and some nifty media-sharing features. Overall, Microsoft's pitch was quite compelling, and the PDC crowd was practically salivating at the chance to play with Microsoft's latest and greatest.

But after the stage props came down, and after the projectors finally went cold, attendees were left with a pre-beta copy of something that looked less like a new OS than the repackaging of an old one. At least that was my impression after I started exploring the Windows 7 M3 (Milestone 3) bits that came on my shiny new 160GB Western Digital USB hard disk (one of the better tchotchkes I've received at a conference). As I reported on my Enterprise Desktop blog, the more I dug into Windows 7, the more I saw an OS that looked and felt like a slightly tweaked version of Windows Vista.

[ Will your PC run Windows 7? Find out with InfoWorld's Windows 7 compatibility calculator. If Windows 7 is a dead end, what's next? Several new personal computing paradigms are emerging. Are Windows 7 critics rushing to judgment? Enterprise Windows' J. Peter Bruzzese says, "Just hold on!" And what's so wrong about Vista, anyway? See "Death match: Windows Vista versus XP." ]

Just what was so new about Microsoft's next Windows, apart from a rejuggled UI? Windows 7 appeared to suck memory like Vista, to consume CPU like Vista, and to have the same consumer focus. How would this product be received by enterprise customers, the vast majority of whom had soundly rejected its predecessor? After all, if Vista wasn't good enough for big business, then surely a Vista-derived encore would meet with a similarly chilly reception.

If any pre-beta software ever called for a close look and benchmark testing, Windows 7 M3 was it. With so many questions to answer, and the fate of Windows in the enterprise hanging in the balance, I rolled up my sleeves and dove in. I started by examining Windows 7's innards -- the kernel and other low-level structures -- then slowly worked my way out to subsystem behavior and application runtime characteristics. Because one of the focal points of Microsoft's keynote presentation was improved performance, I looked for signs that Windows 7 would be faster, more responsive, and less resource-intensive than the bloated Windows Vista.

Close

On Twitter now

Windows

Powered by Twitter

On Twitter now

additional resources
White Paper - 7 Technologies Behind Ultimate Storage Efficiency

White Paper

7 Technologies Behind Ultimate Storage Efficiency

Get the most out of the storage you already own. Download this whitepaper today and examine 7 key technologies behind maximizing your storage efficiency.

Download now »
Insider Threat Deep Dive Report

White Paper

Insider Threat Deep Dive Report

Stop unscrupulous insiders. A clever criminal can lull the boss into believing nothing is amiss. Systems designed to monitor the network for patterns of criminal or destructive behavior are much harder to fool. Learn how to put the right countermeasures in place and vastly reduce the threat posed by insiders.

Download now »
White Paper - A Powerful Platform for Virtualization

White Paper

A Powerful Platform for Virtualization

Examine the 5 unique requirements that virtualization imposes on hardware, and discover how the next generation of HP's ProLiant server line can deliver virtualized, efficient data centers, rapid ROI and lower operational expenses.

Download now »
White Paper - Backup Best Practices for HP EVA and VMware

White Paper

Backup Best Practices for HP EVA and VMware

Address the backup and restore challenges created by virtualized server environments by following these technical recommendations. Learn how VMware Consolidated Backup in conjunction with HP Data Protector can realize a VMware ESX backup that surpasses the 1 TB/h performance threshold, while minimizing storage resources overhead.

Download now »
scott adie 30-Oct-09 7:51am
1 reply
Randall seems to be relying on Microsoft's previous history rather than providing a legitimate evaluation. Subjective analysis benefits only those users who are like-minded, in other words, predisposed to thrash Microsoft. And, we all know Microsoft produces a horrible product which is why there are so many OS competitors out there and only several hundred-million users. Pre-beta? Hmm, I guess it should be evaluated as the consumer release version then huh? People like Randall have no concept of how difficult a task an OS manufacturer undertakes. Consider car manufacturers by comparison. Before the recent collapse, GM had at least 7 divisions each producing multiple models having huge option lists so people could get what they want. The recognized that making one car or truck that would be all-things-to-all-people was impossible. Yet, that is exactly the same task that faces Microsoft. I've struggled with the bugs and quirks of Windows evolution since 1986 just like millions of others have. Some issues have never been satisfactorily resolved among it's different incarnations. But on the other hand, it's always been a relatively inexpensive piece of software and I've made a good living with it over all those years. So yea, sometimes Windows sucks and needs several Service Packs to work out most of the bugs but mostly, thank you Microsoft.
SteveCarl 19-Jul-10 10:12pm
hi, Scott,.
I think so about it,. thanks for sharing your opinion,.
ITjournalist
robin1 16-Dec-09 11:49pm
Great stuff. I'm going to have to read it again to make sure I got it all.70-680

Today's Headlines: First Look Newsletter

Find out what will be news for the day, with our first-thing-in-the-morning briefing.

©1994-2010 Infoworld, Inc.