November 06, 2009

The trouble with S/MIME e-mail encryption

With careful planning, S/MIME can be nearly effortless after the initial install -- until you need to scan, inspect, or search the encrypted messages

A few times a year, I recognize the need for a product where none exists because I hear multiple customers asking for it. This is one of those times. The products that an increasing number of my clients is looking for are e-mail scanning and archiving systems that can handle S/MIME-encrypted messages.

In a normal year, I visit 20 to 40 clients, ranging from small companies to Fortune 10, where I get to see what products they are using and how well these products work in a real-world scenario. Increasingly popular these days is the use of S/MIME and other e-mail encryption methods (such as PGP, proprietary Web mail portals, and so on) to protect e-mail both within the enterprise and externally. S/MIME isn't necessarily the best method to use, but it's a stable, open standard and probably the most common e-mail encryption method I've seen in use.

[ Die, unknown executable! Now that malicious programs outnumber legitimate ones, blocking the bad may give way to allowing the good. See "Test Center review: Whitelisting security offers salvation." ]

Every S/MIME customer I have goes through a few phases. First, they need to understand how it works. How do you turn it on? Who gets what keys? How are the keys distributed? What training will end-users need? How to automate its use? It's no small undertaking.

E-mailing in the dark
Often in the second phase, S/MIME ends up nearly crippling the company's normal e-mail functionality. S/MIME involves encryption, and when you encrypt e-mail, it is no longer searchable. At the very least, users can no longer retrieve past e-mails based upon message text keyword searches, although the e-mail subject line and some other information, such as file attachment name, may remain visible.

This may sound merely bothersome at first, but it becomes mission critical when you need that one single e-mail for proof in a disagreement. Some users respond by turning their e-mail subject lines into more descriptive headings that can be more easily found using keyword searches, but at some point, the sender begins to reveal information that should probably be protected within the S/MIME body.

Worse for today's computer security departments is the fact that S/MIME ends up defanging their anti-virus scanners, DLP (data loss prevention) tools, and e-mail archiving and retrieval systems. Outgoing S/MIME-encrypted e-mail can be anti-virus scanned before encrypting and sending, but it's more difficult to scan incoming S/MIME messages, where the scanning is done on a gateway or by an external service provider. Most of the risk from e-mail malware isn't from the stuff you send, anyway. It's from the stuff sent to you. If you use S/MIME and don't have client-side malware detection for e-mail, you now have a problem.

White Paper

D2D Virtual Tape Library Replication Primer

This whitepaper explains the terminology and concepts behind Data Replication technologies and establishes some sizing rules through worked examples. Learn the new paradigm in disaster tolerance—protect data anywhere.

Download now »

White Paper

An Alternative to Virtualization for Datacenter Cost Savings

Server virtualization is a popular option for dealing with mounting datacenter costs. Another equally promising approach is the use of an Application Delivery Controller. Citrix NetScaler provides a low-cost way for organizations to reduce their server count and accrue cost savings from a reduction in space, cooling, power and personnel.

Download now »

White Paper

Why Your Firewall, VPN, and IEEE 802.11i Aren't Enough to Protect Your Network

The emergence of WLANs has created a new breed of security threats to enterprise networks.

Included in HP ProCurve WLAN solutions is security technology that alleviates threats from WLANs through:
* Monitoring wireless activity inside and out of the enterprise
* Classifying WLAN transmissions into harmful and harmless
* Preventing transmissions that pose a security threat to the enterprise network
* Locating participating devices for physical remediation

Download now »

White Paper

Bringing the Edge to the Data Center

Effectively address data protection challenges, implementing solutions that help store and protect business–critical data while cutting costs and improving efficiency and reliability.

Download now »
DougLor 7-Nov-09 9:36am
Another email encryption option is Voltage SecureMail. It uses Voltage IBE (Identity Based Encryption). Think of IBE as the next generation of PKI that doesn't require certificates for the public key...just an email address. Voltage SecureMail has Outlook plug-ins or a web interface for sending encrypted email. Messages are completely controlled by the sender and recipient. No messages are stored on servers. Organizations can also use a SecureMail gateway to integrate with AV/AS scanners and SMIME (for those who haven't moved away from SMIME...yet). Recipients don't need any special software to decrypt and read their messages. It's much easier to use than PGP or SMIME and just as secure. Try it at: www.voltage.com/vsn

Sign up to receive InfoWorld Resource Alerts

Subscribe to the Today's Headlines: First Look Newsletter

Find out what will be news for the day, with our first-thing-in-the-morning briefing.

White paper

Log Management: How to Develop the Right Strategy for Business and Compliance

This white paper provides guidance on how to develop a strategic approach to managing and monitoring logs, a key function required for compliance with many regulatory mandates and a critical defense against security threats.

Download now! »

White paper

The Essential Series: Security Information Management

Learn about the processes and technologies that support security information management (SIM) operations, as well as the business case for SIM. The series examines different options for implementing SIM and gives you evaluation criteria for selecting the best option for your organization.

Download now! »

White paper

Aberdeen: Choosing and Consuming Managed Security Services

Learn the strategies, actions, and capabilities that Best-in-Class organizations employ and technologies they choose to obtain superior performance against various security performance metrics. This report provides guidelines for identifying which security solutions to consume as a MSS and defines best practices for choosing and managing MSSPs.

Download now! »
©1994-2009 Infoworld, Inc.