The U.S. Federal Communications Commission's national broadband plan released last week contains many good ideas, but it also leaves the door open to new regulations of broadband providers, representatives of providers said Tuesday.
The broadband plan recognizes that private investment will largely pay for the broadband networks of the future, including the goal of bringing 100Mbps of broadband service to 100 million U.S. homes by 2020, said James Cicconi, senior executive vice president for external and legislative affairs at AT&T.
[ Also on InfoWorld: Bill Snyder makes it clear in his Tech's Bottom Line blog: The National Broadband Plan needs to be fixed -- already | Cut straight to the key news for technology development and IT management with our once-a-day summary of the top tech news. Subscribe to the InfoWorld Daily newsletter. ]
But the plan does not, in an outright manner, reject calls from some consumer-focused groups to reclassify broadband providers as common carriers, subject to a broad set of regulations from the FCC, he said during a forum on the broadband plan Tuesday.
FCC officials have predicted the plan will lead to dozens of rulemaking proceedings at the agency, an "odd way" to encourage private investment, Cicconi said.
The plan recognizes that its goals are "best and most likely to be carried out by the private sector continuing to do what it's doing," he said. "The thing I like the least is the fact that it tees up a plethora of rulemakings ... and it fails to close the door on a bunch of other issues that create a great deal of uncertainty that cuts against the very investment they say they want."
The facts in the plan show a major "success story" for broadband deployment in the United States, but the tone of the plan suggests that the FCC believes more government intervention is needed, added Kyle McSlarrow, president and CEO of the National Cable and Telecommunications Association, a trade group representing cable operators.
Nevertheless, Cicconi, McSlarrow, and representatives of Verizon Communications and Intel largely praised the 376-page plan [PDF] during a forum Tuesday, particularly the section of the document that focuses on freeing up 500MHz of new spectrum over the next 10 years for mobile broadband.
"Spectrum is the mother's milk of wireless," said Tom Tauke, Verizon's executive vice president for public affairs, policy and communications. "The recommendations for spectrum will be highly debated but this, I think, gets the ball moving in a significant way in the development of additional spectrum resources for wireless."
The broadband plan identifies available spectrum that can be auctioned by the FCC, but also seeks to recover 120MHz of spectrum from U.S. television broadcasters, a controversial recommendation. Broadcasters would keep or share in the spectrum auction proceeds in exchange for voluntarily giving up unused spectrum, but the National Association of Broadcasters has been cool to the idea.
Despite general praise for the plan, Tauke and Cicconi both said they have concerns about potential regulations resulting from the plan.