November 12, 2009

Deathmatch: Motorola Droid versus iPhone

The iPhone has triumphed over all previous 'iPhone killers.' Does the Droid finally knock the iPhone off its pedestal?

Here we go again: Another swaggering company claims to have the iPhone killer. This time, it's Motorola and Verizon Wireless, with the Droid. You've seen the "Droid does" campaign, but let's cut to the chase: The Motorola Droid does not do that much. It's a real letdown after all the hype, with some amazingly dumb design decisions, such as lack of a multitouch screen (no gesture support) and a hard-to-use keyboard.

Worse for Motorola is that HTC, a company hardly known for its investment in design, has come out with a better Android-based smartphone. The consumer-oriented HTC Droid Eris has a surprisingly good user interface that could teach Apple a thing or two.

[ See which smartphone InfoWorld rates best for business in our six-way ultimate mobile deathmatch -- and create your own ratings with our Mobile Deathmatch Calculator. | Get the full scoop on the HTC Droid Eris in Paul Venezia's review. ]

Despite the flaws, the Droid does show real movement in the high-tech industry to truly compete with the iPhone. The Palm Pre earlier this year was the first credible competitor to Apple, while the Droid and the Droid Eris move that competition along. The iPhone remains the victor, but the number of viable competitors is sure to rise further.

Deathmatch: E-mail, calendars, and contacts
The heart of what a smartphone user does -- maybe even more than talk -- is deal with e-mail and calendars, both of which tap into your contacts database.

The Droid's Email app is superficially similar to the iPhone's, but it lacks much of iPhone Mail's richness. For example, both let you select multiple e-mails for deletion, but the Droid doesn't let you quickly delete a message without reading it (the iPhone does it with a swipe gesture). The Droid's Email app doesn't let you move e-mail into folders, and worse, you can't search e-mails from the Email app in the Droid.

[ Compare the Motorola Droid and iPhone side by side in our Droid vs. iPhone mobile deathmatch slideshow. ]

Although Motorola advertises the Droid as supporting Exchange e-mail, it does so in limited circumstances. If your Exchange server doesn't have any ActiveSync policies enabled, you should be able to access Exchange e-mail from the Droid. If such policies are enabled, the Droid will let you connect to the server and send e-mail (I had to reboot the Droid after Exchange setup to get it to work), but it won't display your messages or folders. (My colleague Paul Venezia's testing shows the Droid can get e-mail from an Exchange server that does not use ActiveSync policies.)

It's not clear if the Droid supports any Exchange ActiveSync policies -- the tech support staffs at Verizon and Motorola had no idea, and the Web sites provide no details. The iPhone doesn't support all ActiveSync policies, but it works with a commonly used subset, and if it can't connect to Exchange due to a policy conflict, it sends you an alert.

Close

On Twitter now

Mobile platforms

Powered by Twitter

On Twitter now

White Paper

D2D Virtual Tape Library Replication Primer

This whitepaper explains the terminology and concepts behind Data Replication technologies and establishes some sizing rules through worked examples. Learn the new paradigm in disaster tolerance—protect data anywhere.

Download now »

White Paper

An Alternative to Virtualization for Datacenter Cost Savings

Server virtualization is a popular option for dealing with mounting datacenter costs. Another equally promising approach is the use of an Application Delivery Controller. Citrix NetScaler provides a low-cost way for organizations to reduce their server count and accrue cost savings from a reduction in space, cooling, power and personnel.

Download now »

White Paper

Why Your Firewall, VPN, and IEEE 802.11i Aren't Enough to Protect Your Network

The emergence of WLANs has created a new breed of security threats to enterprise networks.

Included in HP ProCurve WLAN solutions is security technology that alleviates threats from WLANs through:
* Monitoring wireless activity inside and out of the enterprise
* Classifying WLAN transmissions into harmful and harmless
* Preventing transmissions that pose a security threat to the enterprise network
* Locating participating devices for physical remediation

Download now »

White Paper

Bringing the Edge to the Data Center

Effectively address data protection challenges, implementing solutions that help store and protect business–critical data while cutting costs and improving efficiency and reliability.

Download now »
Highland 12-Nov-09 10:53am
1 reply
Well, you lost your credibility in the very first paragraph. "...amazingly dumb design decisions, such as lack of a multitouch screen (no gesture support)..." The screen does support multitouch, as does the Android software behind it. Gesturing, such as pinch and zoom, is not the same as "multitouch". Unlike the closed Apple environment, the open applications for Android can choose to make use of multitouch or not. Jargon-level reviewers are a dime a dozen.
Galen Gruman 12-Nov-09 12:44pm
2 replies
I respect that people react to usability issues differently. But when you claiom someone is wrong, make sure they are. In this case, it doesn't matter that Android supports multitouch: The Droid's hardware does not, so gestures are not possible on this device. And anyhow, I never I never said that Android doesn't support multitouch; I said the *Motorola Droid* doesn't, and that is 100% true. If you look at my reviews of the Droid Eris, which also uses the Android OS, you'll see that I do say it supports multitouch.
Highland 12-Nov-09 1:42pm
Do you understand the open environment of Android? Guess not. "the *Motorola Droid* doesn't, and that is 100%..." untrue. The default apps do not support pinch and zoom. But, the Droid itself does. Need a demonstration? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cM1JSFXnQpg

Sign up to receive InfoWorld Resource Alerts

Subscribe to the Mobilize Newsletter

Receive the latest news, reviews and discussions on everything mobile.

©1994-2009 Infoworld, Inc.