Review: Puppet vs. Chef vs. Ansible vs. Salt
The leading configuration management and orchestration tools take different paths to server automationFollow @pvenezia
Puppet or Chef? Ansible or Salt?
Whereas Puppet and Chef will appeal to developers and development-oriented shops, Salt and Ansible are much more attuned to the needs of system administrators. Ansible's simple interface and usability fit right into the sys admin mindset, and in a shop with lots of Linux and Unix systems, Ansible is quick and easy to run right out of the gate.
Salt is the sleekest and most robust of the four, and like Ansible it will resonate with sys admins. Highly scalable and quite capable, Salt is hamstrung only by the Web UI.
Puppet is the most mature and probably the most approachable of the four from a usability standpoint, though a solid knowledge of Ruby is highly recommended. Puppet is not as streamlined as Ansible or Salt, and its configuration can get Byzantine at times. Puppet is the safest bet for heterogeneous environments, but you may find Ansible or Salt to be a better fit in a larger or more homogenous infrastructure.
Chef has a stable and well-designed layout, and while it's not quite up to the level of Puppet in terms of raw features, it's a very capable solution. Chef may pose the most difficult learning curve to administrators who lack significant programming experience, but it could be the most natural fit for development-minded admins and development shops.
For more in-depth looks at these tools, read the full reviews:
- Review: Ansible orchestration is a veteran Unix admin's dream
- Review: Chef cooks up configuration management
- Review: Puppet 3.0 pulls more strings
- Review: Salt keeps server automation simple
|Puppet 3.0||Chef 11.4||Ansible 1.3||Salt 0.17|
|Pricing||Free open source version; Puppet Enterprise costs $100 per machine per year||Free open source version; Enterprise Chef free for 5 machines, $120 per month for 20 machines, $300 per month for 50 machines, $600 per month for 100 machines, and so on||Free open source version; AWX free for 10 machines, then $100 or $250 per machine per year depending on support||Free open source version; SaltStack Enterprise costs $150 per node per year, with volume discounts and site licenses available|
This article, "Review: Puppet vs. Chef vs. Ansible vs. Salt," was originally published at InfoWorld.com. Follow the latest developments in application development, cloud computing, and open source at InfoWorld.com. For the latest business technology news, follow InfoWorld.com on Twitter.