Enterasys, McAfee, Symantec, and Trend Micro tackle our user access control scenarios
Our test infrastructure for the NAC reviews included an edge switch for the client systems, a core switch with server VLANs for the common and secured servers, and a RADIUS server for authentication. Client systems connected into the edge switch, authenticated as defined for the specific scenarios, then accessed (or attempted to access) the various areas of the network: Internet, enterprise, and limited access. We created additional policy networks for remediation and scanning as well.
For the tests, we created policies for each of the following user scenarios when possible: guest users, authenticated guest users, enterprise users, enterprise users with special access, and guest or enterprise systems with policy violations.
For some of the products, not all of the user scenarios applied, so we created scenarios that made sense for each product and made note of the distinctions. In most cases, we used VLAN assignment to move devices into the appropriate policy. In the case of the Enterasys solution, we chose the better option of using port-based policies.
In the end, we discovered that all four systems worked as advertised. The important differences in capabilities and limitations we found were mainly the result of the different approaches these vendors have taken to policy-based access control.
The test results outlined any policies that the system is not designed to enforce and success in those that it can enforce. Key criteria for evaluation were manageability, policy enforcement, scalability, reporting, setup, and value. All of these products show that the NAC marketplace is maturing, the products are improving, and there is still room for innovation.
You may still be better off sticking with Win7 or Win8.1, given the wide range of ongoing Win10...
Early results look promising: the many-hours-long Win7 waits may be behind us
Now that we're down to the wire, many upgraders report that the installer hangs. If this happens to...
Want to get started in machine learning? Google has you covered with high-quality data sets, both big...
Some of the best third-party PC software around has been usurped by native Windows 10 tools and...
The company is removing UML support in Visual Studio 15 due to a lack of usage
VMware private clouds will gain elasticity from the Amazon-VMware offering, but customers may...