Riverbed Steelhead boosts WAN data flow

Enhanced protocol support broadens appliance family's reach

IT always seems to be caught in the middle of the WAN-performance battle: On one hand, users never seem to be happy with an application’s performance; on the other, the bean counters won’t budget for bigger pipes. If more bandwidth isn’t the answer to end-users’ performance problems, then what is?

The solution to improving both response time and circuit utilization is to make the connection more efficient and to reduce the effects of latency. I’ve watched a whole new breed of WAN optimization and acceleration appliances come to market during the past few years, and I’ve seen firsthand what a difference intelligent optimization can make on WAN response time.

Once again, I had Riverbed's Steelhead WAN acceleration and optimization appliances on my test bed, and true to form, the company provided excellent improvements with little tweaking. Release 3 of the RiOS (Riverbed Optimization System) shows a more mature product, with the focus on improving existing features, the addition of greater application support, and much increased capacity. During its time on my bench, Steelhead proved again that it is more than capable of making oversubscribed WAN circuits appear faster than they were while greatly reducing response time, besting previous releases by as much as 20 percent.

I tested three Steelhead appliances: the 200, the 5520, and the 6020. The 5520 (offering 155Mbps of optimized throughput and 15,000 TCP connections) and the 6020 (boasting 310Mbps of optimized throughput and 40,000 TCP connections) are hardware platforms released this year -- as are their cousins, the 3020 and the 3520.

I set up the 5520 as the branch-office appliance and the 6020 as the datacenter unit. (The complete solution requires at least two appliances.) The impish 200 (1Mbps of optimized throughput and 100 TCP connections) came into play during testing of optimization of asymmetric routes (more on this later). My trusty Shunra VE simulated my various WAN conditions, and D-Link DGS-3324SR Gigabit switches tied it all together.

Click for larger view.
Maturing Gracefully

RiOS has always included optimizations for CIFS and MAPI aimed at reducing the protocols’ chattiness. In RiOS 3, Riverbed builds on this solid foundation with the addition of NFS streamlining. As with CIFS traffic, there is a lot of protocol overhead with NFS that can degrade application response time significantly. RiOS 2.1 performed NFS optimization via data and transport streaming; RiOS 3 does NFS application streaming, allowing for read-ahead and metadata pre-fetching. Unfortunately, I do not have any NFS performance numbers from previous releases, but Riverbed’s internal testing shows a 10-fold improvement in RiOS 3. CIFS traffic gained an improvement of between three and six times compared with last year’s testing.

CIFS traffic also received additional application-specific acceleration for programs -- such as SolidWorks, Visio 2003, and SolidEdge -- that open a file multiple times during a single operation. Previously, Steelhead would not optimize subsequent requests for the locked file, erring on the side of data integrity. The new CIFS mode, called overlapping opens, allows Steelhead to continue to optimize CIFS traffic even though Windows has the file locked, improving response times even under these conditions.

This release also does away with the need for a software agent to reside on a server in order to pre-populate an appliance’s cache to eliminate the “cold hit” penalty. RiOS’s pre-population service will load data from any CIFS file share, such as Windows, Netapp, and EMC, into cache on a recurring schedule or on demand (manual). IT can still use the RCU (Riverbed Copy Utility), available in the previous release, but the new pre-population service makes it obsolete.

Quality and Quantity

Enforcement available in the Steelhead appliance yields better support of QoS (quality of service). Previously, RiOS could set QoS tags but could not impose QoS policy on traffic. With Release 3, not only can it enforce policies, but it can do so based on bandwidth and latency. This means IT can define QoS policies based on a class of traffic’s priority -- in terms of delay -- and not just the bandwidth required. This is really important when protecting latency-sensitive traffic such as VoIP and streaming video. RiOS can apply QoS to both TCP and UDP protocols and optimized and passed-through traffic.

Not all WANs, intentionally or not, return packets via the same path, creating asymmetric routes. For a WAN optimization appliance to function correctly, the devices at each end of the circuit have to pass the same packets in and out. With asymmetric routing, a packet may go out one appliance but return through a different path, breaking the optimization process.

RiOS can correct client-side and server-side asymmetric routing issues by forwarding the misrouted packets to a second Steelhead appliance -- also located at the client location -- that is inline with the original traffic. Although this does require at least two Steelheads and knowledge of the WANs traffic flows, admins can still create optimization policies regardless of how packets move between sites.

Seeing Is Believing

One criticism of WAN optimization appliances is that the packets are mangled by the optimization process and traditional network monitoring tools are blind to the traffic. To help admins know how their WAN is functioning, Steelheads can now export traffic flow information to NetFlow collectors. I tested this using Scrutinizer from Plixer International and was impressed by how much information about my WAN was being captured and recorded. All information -- such as source and destination ports and IP addresses -- was preserved.

The reporting engine in RiOS 3 is better than the last time I tested, with small but useful changes to graphs and charts. I can now view charts at one-second intervals and can choose a custom time interval. For example, I created a bandwidth optimization report starting at midnight of the current day to 18:00 hours. Previously I could only select hour, day, week, and month as time intervals. A few new reports, such as WAN interface throughput and connection pooling, are also built in.

Riverbed’s Steelhead family comprises some of the best, easiest-to-deploy-and-maintain WAN optimization appliances on the market. I like that I can set up my optimization scheme with a few simple mouse clicks; there aren’t myriad choices and settings to define. The newest release improves on scalability and even on its already impressive data-reduction numbers. The NetFlow support is a welcome addition as are the new graphs and charts. All in all, Steelhead is still the target most other vendors aim for.

InfoWorld Scorecard
Performance (40.0%)
Setup (10.0%)
Protocol support (25.0%)
Reliability (15.0%)
Value (10.0%)
Overall Score (100%)
Riverbed Steelhead with RiOS 3.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0 9.0