JackBe Presto and Nexaweb Enterprise Web 2.0 Suite converge on a powerful and productive model for server-side mashups supporting AJAX clients
Nexaweb, on the other hand, began as a Java-based framework for building client-server applications that connected a set of XML-defined widgets to a set of data sources through a J2EE server. It offered the kind of client-server framework that Presto now offers -- but it sent this information to a Java-based tool on the client. Now, the company has built an AJAX version for deploying the client, giving developers another pathway for your application.
The Presto approach
I tested the mechanism by building a few mashups that pulled data from RSS feeds and a database. The tool is a pretty nice Swiss Army Knife for mixing together different data sources. The JackBe folks argue that putting so much security control into the server is a logical approach for cautious developers. Presto Edge can poll servers behind the firewall and clean up the data before sending it out to the client. Without it running interference, the only solution would be bolstering the security of each and every service you wanted to expose to the outside world.
A Java client is also useful in other ways. The Java APIs are rich with code for doing simple things such as loading local files and arcane things such as parsing image files. The Nexaweb Java client leaves these options open to you -- if you have client computers that are happy to open themselves up to the software. You can just link them into your code.
I tested the Nexaweb toolkit (Nexaweb Platform 4.5 and Nexaweb Studio 3.5) by building another tool that would mash up RSS feeds and display them in a browser. Nexaweb's back end offers many of the same features as Presto in different packaging. You can grab information from Web services, Web sites, and databases and then send them back over the "Internet Messaging Bus" to the client. The server can poll most of the same basic sources as Presto, but it can't manipulate the information as readily. Nexaweb's server doesn't have the same support for quick manipulation. You could certainly whip up most of this on your own, but it isn't as simple.
Drag and drop, you say
One of my pet peeves is that the marketing forces for both of these packages tend to suggest that building an application with Nexaweb or Presto Studio can be done without requiring any code to be written. Ha. Just because both applications include neat drag-and-drop tools that construct XML to describe the widget layout doesn't mean that you don't need to think abstractly and try to guess what the API wants to do. In both cases, I admit I was charmed by the quick ways to drag an RSS data source onto a table to produce a nice feed reader; I was also driven to tears by nasty little glitches that were the visual equivalents of sign errors. These are sophisticated systems that make life far easier, but you still have to think like a programmer.
The biggest competitor for both of these applications may be services like Yahoo Pipes, Google Gadgets, Metaplace, and any of the other mashup tools for the worlds of Facebook or Salesforce.com. These tools can similarly pull data from a number of sources, mix it up, and then deliver it to Web pages. They're simple and often free, or close to free.
Most IT professionals may be scared of such freedom, and with good reason. If the Nexaweb or Presto server does the mashing, it can decide on the rules for sharing information with the world. Control remains behind the firewall, not with some distant server farm owned by someone else. The downside of this tightfisted approach is that your customers will never surprise you with cool new applications or mashups, something that can be exciting until the so-called customers discover a way to embarrass or rob you. The obvious solution is to open up as many databases as practical but use tools such as JackBe Presto or Nexaweb to do the heavy lifting for more proprietary things.
The biggest customers for these products will be IT professionals with a deadline and a need to integrate a number of internal data sources. If the boss says that the customers need a single place to pull data and reports that tap disparate systems from different parts of the organization, then these are both good tools for creating a rich and usable application that hides some of the confusion going on in the background. They are even more valuable if the hidden sources can't be changed because the developer is long gone, too busy, or uncooperative. Scraping information from the other sources and integrating it all into one front end is quite useful. Both Nexaweb and JackBe Presto are ideal tools for the folks responsible for moving an enterprise's Web presence into Web 2.0 and beyond.
Ease of development (30.0%)
Overall Score (100%)
|JackBe Presto 1.3.1||7.0||9.0||7.0||8.0||9.0|
|Nexaweb Enterprise Web 2.0 Suite||8.0||8.0||8.0||9.0||8.0|
Looking for the missing free copy icon? It's been replaced. There's a new direct link that works like a...
Supreme Court's decision is bad news for developers targeting the U.S. market, who will now have to...
The transition from command line to line-of-command requires a new mind-set -- and a thick skin
Microsoft’s latest OS shows polish, promise, and pain almost everywhere you look
Dealing with telcos and carriers for enterprise circuit installation is still a royal pain. Haven't we...
Did Microsoft go to school on InfoWorld's proposal for an improved version of Windows 8 as it developed...
With licensing restrictions that favor individual users and open source developers, the free-to-use...