Microsoft ships XP Mode RC, calls it tool of last resort

Company says it 'never guessed' that users would be so confused and think the add-on was the only way to run XP apps in Windows 7

Microsoft Tuesday delivered the release candidate of Windows XP Mode, but at the same time downplayed the Windows 7 add-on, saying it was a last resort for customers who want to run old software in the new operating system.

Announced last April and issued as a beta several weeks later, XP Mode creates a virtual environment using Virtual PC, Microsoft's client virtualization technology, then stuffs it with a pre-activated licensed copy of Windows XP Service Pack 3 (SP3), the current version of the 8-year-old operating system. Users can launch XP applications within the virtual machine from the Windows 7 desktop, and those programs appear in Windows 7 windows, rather than in a windowed virtual machine.

[ InfoWorld's Randall C. Kennedy calls Windows 7's 'XP mode' the right idea, wrong technology. | Find out why Microsoft's own App-V would be a better solution to support the XP legacy.]

But while today's XP Mode Release Candidate (RC) includes several improvements over the beta, including the ability to connect to USB devices directly from the Windows 7 toolbar and the option to disable file sharing between the two operating systems, Scott Woodgate, director of Windows enterprise and virtualization strategy, had bigger fish to fry.

"XP Mode is for those situations when users have tried [running XP applications] on all the other avenues," Woodgate said in an interview today. "It's the last mile for XP compatibility."

Woodgate acknowledged that Microsoft had not made that clear months ago when it unveiled XP Mode. "We always had that clearly in our minds, but we didn't articulate it to customers," he said. "Windows 7 is always going to be the better choice for running XP applications."

Many XP applications will run "just fine on Windows 7," Woodgate claimed. "The best experience will be running XP applications on Windows 7."

In a blog post announcing XP Mode RC this morning, Woodgate noted that many XP programs run in Windows Vista, and because Windows 7 uses the same underpinnings as its immediate predecessor, those applications should also run without problems in the new OS. "In most cases, we recommend running applications natively in Windows 7," Woodgate said in his post.

Woodgate denied that Microsoft was backing off recommending XP Mode because some analysts had criticized the virtual environment as a support nightmare that would require users and companies to manage two different operating systems, keeping both patched and running two separate copies of security software.

"[Our recommendations now] are more a result of users being confused," Woodgate said. "We never guessed that users would think they had to run every XP application in there."

Microsoft has pitched XP Mode primarily to small- and medium-sized businesses, and has promised to update MED-V (Microsoft Enterprise Desktop Virtualization) to help companies manage the XP virtual machines on workers' desktops. However, MED-V is available only to organizations that have a Software Assurance plan in place and also purchase Microsoft Desktop Optimization Pack (MDOP).

MED-V 2.0 will be available in beta within 90 days of the launch of Windows 7, Woodgate promised.

The ship date for XP Mode is a little cloudier. "We hope to release it at the same time as Windows 7," Woodgate said, "But as always, we'll ship based on quality."

Microsoft has not changed its plans to offer XP Mode to users of Windows Home Premium, Woodgate added. "This is not a typical consumer thing," he said. XP Mode RC is available only to users of Windows 7 Professional, Ultimate and Enterprise, either pre-installed on PCs by computer manufacturers or as an after-market free add-on. Hewlett-Packard is one of the OEMs (original equipment manufacturers) that has promised to install it on the machines they sell, Woodgate said.

He also said Microsoft is working with some software developers, particularly security vendors, to encourage them to provide multiple licenses with their software so that users can install one product on both Windows 7 and the virtualized XP. Security software makers have the technical information they need to create products that can scan not only Windows 7 files, but also those in XP Mode, Woodgate said.

"Do I need to use antivirus in XP Mode?" he asked rhetorically. "Absolutely yes."

Windows XP Mode can be downloaded starting today from Microsoft's Web site. It requires Windows 7 RC or RTM, the latter the final code that the company announced two weeks ago. XP Mode also requires an additional 1GB of memory, 15GB of hard disk space and processor-based virtualization support.

This story, "Microsoft ships XP Mode RC, calls it tool of last resort" was originally published by Computerworld.

Mobile Security Insider: iOS vs. Android vs. BlackBerry vs. Windows Phone
Join the discussion
Be the first to comment on this article. Our Commenting Policies