Web-based editions of Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and OneNote are underwhelming at best
Is the era of desktop software over? With the general release of Office 2010 this week, Microsoft seems to be sending a mixed message. On the one hand, Office 2010 is the slickest, most feature-rich version of the suite to date. That's a clear challenge to Google, which offers a simpler, Web-based alternative to Office in the form of Google Docs. On the other hand, the simultaneous release of the Office 2010 Web Apps seems to vindicate Google's strategy by duplicating Office functionality on the Web. So which is it?
My first impression of the prerelease versions of the Office Web Apps was that they were remarkably polished. Office documents displayed flawlessly, with fidelity unmatched by any Web-based competitor. Many features were missing, however -- most notably the ability to edit documents -- so my ultimate assessment was reserved. Now that Office 2010 has shipped, I thought it high time to revisit the suite to see what Microsoft has actually delivered. Are the Office Web Apps a true competitor to Google Docs, a valuable addition to the Office product family, or merely a Web-based novelty?
[ Also on InfoWorld: From powerful productivity enhancers to important security safeguards, the new Microsoft Office has a number of features that businesses will love. See "Top 10 Office 2010 features for business." ]
Office Web Apps: Broad platform and browser support
First off, the Office Web Apps' browser support is to be commended. Officially Microsoft is supporting only recent versions of Firefox, Internet Explorer, and Safari, but in practice most standards-compliant browsers appear to work equally well (including Google Chrome). Gone, seemingly, are the days when Microsoft tried to shoehorn customers into IE with ActiveX controls and nonstandard Web features.
That's not to say Microsoft's offering is completely platform-agnostic, however. The Web Apps resemble Microsoft Office, but it's the Windows version of Office 2010, complete with the Ribbon interface. Users of the free Web Apps access their files through SkyDrive, Microsoft's online storage service, which presents files and folders using Windows-like fonts and icons. Business users access files via SharePoint Server 2010. Where the Google Docs UI is lean, spare, and generic, the Office Web Apps give enough gentle nudges toward Windows that Mac OS X users, in particular, may be put off.
Since the Web Apps feel most natural on Windows, I did most of my testing on Windows 7 running IE8, with Silverlight installed. Silverlight is not required, but it improves font rendering and enhances some features, such as file uploading. I also installed Office 2010 to test its integration with the Web Apps.
I chose to test the free, consumer version of the Web Apps because that version will have the broadest appeal. Microsoft will also offer two versions for business customers: a SaaS edition hosted on Microsoft's servers, and an on-premise rendition that comes bundled with site licenses of Office 2010. The core functionality of all three is identical, but both business versions offer additional collaboration features through integration with SharePoint 2010.
How far does Swift soar over Objective-C? Let us count the ways
Gordon Moore talks about his famous observation that paved the way for faster, smaller and cheaper...
Appboy's on-stage presentation at Demo Traction on April 22, 2015
Sponsored by Nuage Networks
Sponsored by Fibre Channel Industry Association
The few changes at worst do no harm to IT and in some cases may make things a little easier or safer
Charter's proposed merger with Time Warner may pass FCC scrutiny, but the outcome for consumers is...
All software has bugs, but even the most well known applications can have errors and vulnerabilities...
Is Eclipse overkill? Is Vim not enough? Then check out the new generation of code editors, led by...