Nexus 4 review: Google's instantly obsolete Android smartphone

Besides its lack of LTE, there's nothing horribly wrong -- or particularly compelling -- with Google's 'pure Android' device

Page 2 of 2

Two new approaches to video-out support
Less useful -- today, at least -- is the addition of support for the Miracast wireless display standard, which the industry group behind the Wi-Fi standard has created in hopes of providing a vendor-neutral alternative to Apple's compelling but proprietary AirPlay technology. Miracast replaces the DLNA standard that quickly became fragmented due to semiproprietary, incompatible versions meant to steer customers to buying all gear from one company. The Miracast notion is a good one, and the Wi-Fi Alliance's backing gives it instant credibility. But you can't get Miracast devices yet, so it has zero utility for now. Perhaps that will change in a year.

It makes sense for Google to adopt Miracast given DLNA's failure to blunt AirPlay, but its adoption of the SlimPort HDMI technology in the Nexus 4 makes less sense. It brings to three the types of video-out connectors in the Android world, after the MicroHDMI port available on some devices and the MHL-compatible MicroUSB port available on some others. Like MHL, SlimPort uses the MicroUSB port but provides extra pins to transmit video, so device makers don't need a separate MicroHDMI port. But MHL cables don't work with SlimPort or vice versa.

Adding insult to injury, Google's three Nexus devices don't even use the same video-out technology: The Nexus 4 uses SlimPort HDMI, the Nexus 10 uses MicroHDMI, and the Nexus 7 has no video-out-compatible port at all. Each is made by a different manufacturer, but you'd think that Google would have made the technical requirements the same for such a core technology.

It's basic hardware, otherwise
The other unique hardware feature in the Nexus 4 is its support for so-called wireless power (inductive charging), a dubious technology that wastes energy and requires space-gobbling mats. It's a toy, not a useful capability.

Other than LTE support, the Nexus 4 has the hardware you'd expect on a modern smartphone, including Bluetooth radio, Wi-Fi (with Wi-Fi Direct support), near-field communications (NFC) short-range radio for touch-initiated sharing and payments, front and rear cameras with rear LED flash, and audio jack. It felt perfectly responsive and didn't suffer the app crashes I experienced in the Nexus 10 tablet. The Nexus 4 is a perfectly serviceable smartphone, as long as you don't plan on using LTE while you own it.

But for the privilege of owning a middling smartphone without LTE, you'll pay much more than you would for a premium Android smartphone or iPhone. The Nexus 4 costs $300 for the anemic 8GB model and $400 for the 16GB model, versus $100 to $200 for equivalent high-end smartphones. The reason is that you're paying the full cost of the Nexus 4; the carriers don't subsidize its price as they do most smartphones. (An unsubsidized high-end smartphone can cost $550 to $650 for the equivalent storage capacity.)

Even though the carriers save the subsidy costs, they don't necessarily give you a break on the service costs -- AT&T charges the same whether you bring your own phone or not, while T-Mobile provides a discounted monthly service fee for some of its plans if you bring your own phone. So, in most cases, all you gain is the ability to switch carriers without paying an early termination fee, which happens to be about the same as the extra cost of the Nexus 4. The economics just don't work.

As an unlocked smartphone not tied to a specific U.S. carrier's network, the Nexus 4 can run on any compatible carrier, which means T-Mobile or AT&T in the States. That's very limited portability. As for use overseas, most U.S. carriers let you use their locked smartphones abroad on local carriers' networks by swapping the SIM card, so chances are you are already unlocked for foreign access. Also, you can easily get a subsidized smartphone that is unlocked for overseas use.

If you really want to take advantage of the power of Android, you're better off with a Galaxy S III or other high-end model.

This article, "Nexus 4 review: Google's instantly obsolete Android smartphone," was originally published at InfoWorld.com. Follow the latest developments in mobile computing, read Galen Gruman's Mobile Edge blog at InfoWorld.com, follow Galen's mobile musings on Twitter, and follow InfoWorld on Twitter.

| 1 2 Page 2
From CIO: 8 Free Online Courses to Grow Your Tech Skills
Notice to our Readers
We're now using social media to take your comments and feedback. Learn more about this here.