Free Newsletters
Technology & Business Daily

InfoWorld
Log-in | Register

Supersmart phones for extreme mobility

We pick seven serious business phones with all the bells and whistles, plus the power and flexibility that real mobile professionals need


The Nokia OSS browser doesn't support tabs or multiple windows. Instead, pressing the Back button brings up a set of thumbnails for the pages you've visited so that you can randomly jump among them. The OSS browser is extremely fast at redrawing pages from cache, and it has excellent JavaScript performance.

Embedded Java works perfectly in Nokia's browser, but embedded media launches an external Real Player. Sites that insist on wrapping media playback in JavaScript or Flash won't work this way, but audio and video on your intranet will work just fine, as will Flash content downloaded to the E61i for stand-alone playback. The E61i ships with an older release of Flash Lite. Adobe's Web site offers a free upgrade to the latest release.

Symbian Series 60's principle of "write once, run on any phone" hits a snag with the 3rd Edition. Code signing requirements and binary interface changes in the 3rd Edition platform can cause some existing native and Java S60 applications to quit working or refuse to install on 3rd Edition devices. Series 60 is so overwhelmingly popular worldwide that the majority of S60 projects in active development have already adjusted to 3rd Edition foibles.

The E61i needs IT's hand in deployment. It has more configurable options than any wireless device I've used, although it's certainly no harder to configure than a desktop PC. Fortunately, IT, or an S60 power user or developer, can tune a single device to perfection, capture that configuration, and apply it to multiple devices. That configuration can be reapplied in case a curious user gets in trouble, and handset features can be hidden and disabled using Nokia management software.

Lastly, the E61i is not an "oh, and it also makes phone calls" device. It is an enterprise handset that is a Nokia phone through and through. That means it's a best-in-class voice device with integrated PDA functionality, rich standards support, and an easy-to-use Windows sync and management UI. It has Bluetooth file browse/transfer support on Mac systems, and E61i will gateway Windows and Mac notebooks to the handset's wireless Internet connection. Nokia's E61i is, by all measures and across all mobile platforms, the best enterprise wireless handset for the money.

Mobile executive: Nokia E65 and T-Mobile Wing
A mobile executive's phone needs to possess all of the qualities of an enterprise phone, including VPN, rich document viewing and editing, push messaging, and no-compromises compatibility with an enterprise's custom mobile software. It also must look good enough that you don't need to duck into a hallway or turn your back to the group to use it.

I've chosen two phones that fit what I consider to be the executive device profile. The Nokia E65 and the T-Mobile Wing (HTC Herald) represent the top end of their platforms' capabilities in out-of-the-box functionality and customizability — Symbian Series 60 3rd Edition and Windows Mobile 6 Professional, respectively — so there's no enterprise application they won't run. Both are also extremely compact. They pocket discreetly without a case or holster and they are presentable even in formal settings.

Nokia's E65 is identical in functionality to the E61i, but without the alphanumeric keyboard and large display. The E65 replaces these with a tall portrait-type display and a slide-out 12-key dialpad. Even though the display is the same resolution as the E61i's, text is drawn across 240 pixels instead of 320. The impact on readability is noticeable, and the E65 also lacks the E61i's ability to flip to a landscape view. There is a third-party utility that does this for you, but it's something that Nokia should provide out of the box. I'd use the E65 in landscape mode most of the time.

The E65's predictive text entry helps mitigate the pain of 12-key typing; C-level execs don't text the likes of "CU@12" to each other. Nokia supplies quick-reply message templates that usually leave only one variable, like time or location, to fill in. It's worth noting as well that the E65, like the E61i, supports all popular instant messaging services and standards.

In a clear nod to managers and executives, E65 dedicates a key to conference calling, a process that the handset automates on your behalf. A Team Suite application lets you organize contact list entries into groups. The team works as a mailing and messaging list, and you can share browser bookmarks among team members, but if everybody's on the same wireless service you can convene a sort of pushed conference call in one operation. Each team member's phone rings, and when they answer, they're put on hold until the conference leader kicks off the call. On wireless networks that support push-to-talk (PTT), team members are automatically placed in a PTT group. Matching functionality exists on the E61i.

Tom Yager is chief technologist of the InfoWorld Test Center. He also writes InfoWorld's Ahead of the Curve and Enterprise Mac blogs.
Continued
« PREVIOUS PAGE | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | NEXT PAGE » 

 The Bottom Line

AT&T 8525 (HTC Hermes)
AT&T, att.com

Fair  6.3
criteria score weight
Extensibility 7 20%
Messaging 6 20%
Networking 7 20%
Usability 5 20%
Multimedia 8 10%
Value 5 10%

Cost:
$599.99 retail; $349.99 with two-year AT&T contract

Platforms:
Windows Mobile 5 Pocket PC Edition; Windows XP or Vista required for desktop sync

Bottom Line:
The AT&T 8525 (HTC Hermes) is a fatter, faster version of the T-Mobile Wing, but in a silvertone case. The thumbwheel, macro-focus camera, and infrared are nice touches, but the 8525 is an old-fashioned brick that's uncomfortable to hold. At present, AT&T is still shipping the 8525 with Windows Mobile 5, and a promised update to Windows Mobile 6 Professional is not available.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology

 The Bottom Line

BlackBerry 8300 (Curve)
Research In Motion, blackberry.com

Good  7.4
criteria score weight
Extensibility 7 20%
Messaging 9 20%
Networking 7 20%
Usability 7 20%
Multimedia 8 10%
Value 6 10%

Cost:
$539 unlocked; $199.99 with two-year AT&T contract (currently $0 with rebate on amazon.com)

Platforms:
BlackBerry Desktop backup, restore, upload requires Windows; included Roxio Media Manager (Windows) converts video and audio for playback; Mac OS X PDA sync and upload with PocketMac (free download from blackberry.com); device is programmable in Java using free RIM-supported tools; optional BlackBerry Enterprise Server software links to existing messaging server

Bottom Line:
BlackBerry 8300 (Curve) kicks off a new trend toward more relaxed, lifestyle-friendly devices for individuals. Curve is a full BlackBerry with a QWERTY keyboard and trackball, but in a smaller, more shapely package with Bluetooth stereo audio, a two-megapixel still camera with light, and Windows software for converting video and audio for playback on the device.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology

 The Bottom Line

BlackBerry 8800
Research In Motion, blackberry.com

Very Good  8.0
criteria score weight
Extensibility 7 20%
Messaging 10 20%
Networking 7 20%
Usability 8 20%
Multimedia 7 10%
Value 9 10%

Cost:
$549 to $599 unlocked; $299 to $349 with two-year contract

Platforms:
BlackBerry Desktop backup, restore, upload requires Windows; Mac OS X PDA sync and upload with PocketMac (free download from blackberry.com); device is programmable in Java using free RIM-supported tools; optional BlackBerry Enterprise Server software links to existing messaging server

Bottom Line:
The BlackBerry 8800 is already established as the flagship BlackBerry handset on GSM/GPRS/EDGE networks. This rich and easy-to-use device stands apart for its trackball, comfortable shape, perfected keyboard, built-in GPS with standard navigation software, and unparalleled battery life supporting 22 days standby on a single charge.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology

 The Bottom Line

HTC Advantage X7501
HTC, htc.com

Very Good  8.4
criteria score weight
Extensibility 8 20%
Messaging 8 20%
Networking 10 20%
Usability 9 20%
Multimedia 7 10%
Value 7 10%

Cost:
$899

Platforms:
Windows Mobile 6 Professional; syncs with Windows Outlook (trial version included); C++ and .NET Compact Framework and Visual Studio 2005 are used to develop custom apps

Bottom Line:
Finally, a Windows Mobile device that almost makes you want to leave your notebook PC at home. The X7501 is an absolute beauty, with a sharp five-inch display, a snap-on QWERTY keyboard, fast Wi-Fi, an 8GB microdrive, and video output. The X7501 is not cheap, but it'll make you and everyone who sees you with it forget all about the iPhone.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology

 The Bottom Line

Nokia E61i
Nokia, nokia.com

Very Good  8.3
criteria score weight
Extensibility 9 20%
Messaging 7 20%
Networking 10 20%
Usability 8 20%
Multimedia 7 10%
Value 8 10%

Cost:
$699.99 retail; $450 estimated street

Platforms:
Symbian Series 60 3rd Edition; supports C++, Java, JavaScript, Perl, and Python custom applications; Windows desktop management and sync suite and Mac file sync included

Bottom Line:
Nokia’s E61i is an exceptional QWERTY handset nearly overloaded with connectivity, customizability, and out-of-the-box applications. VoIP, hands and eyes-free operation, Office document editing, and an oversized display that’s readable even in direct sunlight top this handset’s long list of distinguishing features.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology

 The Bottom Line

Nokia E65
Nokia, nokia.com

Very Good  8.1
criteria score weight
Extensibility 9 20%
Messaging 7 20%
Networking 10 20%
Usability 7 20%
Multimedia 7 10%
Value 8 10%

Cost:
$699.99 retail; $430 estimated street (unlocked)

Platforms:
Symbian Series 60 3rd Edition; supports C++, Java, JavaScript, Perl, and Python custom applications; Windows desktop management and sync suite and Mac file sync included

Bottom Line:
Would Nokia's E61i be your dream handset if it weren't so big? The E65 is essentially the E61i done as a handsome executive phone with a slide-out numeric keypad. The E65 is expensive for a phone, and Nokia didn't do as well as I'd hoped at adapting the 12-key keyboard to use in Web apps. Still, the E65 is a rare, pocketable, boardroom-compatible enterprise handset that will integrate with any solution built around Nokia's E61i or comparable QWERTY handset.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology

 The Bottom Line

T-Mobile Wing (HTC Herald)
T-Mobile, tmobile.com

Very Good  8.1
criteria score weight
Extensibility 7 20%
Messaging 8 20%
Networking 9 20%
Usability 9 20%
Multimedia 7 10%
Value 8 10%

Cost:
$499 retail; currently $299 with two-year T-Mobile contract

Platforms:
Windows Mobile 6 Professional; syncs with Windows Outlook (trial version included); C++ and .NET Compact Framework and Visual Studio 2005 are used to develop custom apps

Bottom Line:
T-Mobile Wing, a Windows Mobile 6 Professional handset, is an attractive yet full-featured device. Windows Mobile 6 Professional, with Mobile Office 2007, really shines on Wing, which has a roomy slide-out QWERTY keyboard and a screen that responds to stylus and fingertip. T-Mobile lacks 3G coverage, but Wing's Wi-Fi kicks in on your LAN and wherever there's a T-Mobile Hotspot.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology


Talkback:

commentPost a Comment

 

MOST COMMENTS

 
 





Dialing up Agility with Business Transformation
Is your organization innovating quickly enough to meet their needs, drive your business goals, and rise above the competition? Business Integration - leveraging the power of BPM and SOA - is the key to making the transition from the fragmented enterprise to a connected one. Register to attend this live webcast now!

»  Click here to view this Webcast
  Zombie PCs Are Attacking Your LAN
A recent study showed that malware-infected zombie PCs are now a bigger threat to ISPs and Web infrastructure than DoS attacks. As this brand new IT Strategy Guide explains, an increased use of peer-to-peer techniques by the attackers has made it harder to fight back. Download now, compliments of Verio:

»  Click here to download now

- Special Advertising Partners -
WHITE PAPERS
 

» Technology White Papers Library

Technology White Papers by Topic

Technology White Papers E-mail Alert

Find out when the latest white paper is available:
 
 
INFOWORLD MARKETPLACE
 
» BUY A LINK NOW
 
 

Video

 
 
 

Podcasts

 
 
 

 

Columnists

 
 
 

Resource Center


Ads by techwords beta  [See your link here]
 




Sponsored Technology Links

 
 
 HOME  NEWS  BLOGS  PODCASTS  VIDEOS  TECHNOLOGIES  TEST CENTER  EVENTS  CAREERS   About | Advertise | Awards | RSS | Contact Us 

Copyright © 2008, Reprints, Permissions, Licensing, IDG Network, Privacy Policy, Terms of Service.
All Rights reserved. InfoWorld is a leading publisher of technology information and product reviews on topics including viruses,
phishing, worms, firewalls, security, servers, storage, networking, wireless, databases, and web services.

CIO :: ComputerWorld :: CSO :: Demo :: GamePro :: Games.net :: IDG Connect :: IDG World Expo
Industry Standard :: IT World :: JavaWorld :: LinuxWorld :: MacUser :: Macworld :: Network World :: PC World :: Playlist