The BlackBerry browser is vastly improved, taking on the desktop view that's enabled by the trackball. Perhaps this browser
is the best that can be done in Java, but it's well behind other mobile browsers discussed here. The BlackBerry 8800 can spend
several minutes chewing on scripts and styles for a Web 2.0-ey page such as the InfoWorld.com landing page. Dealing with the pain of desktop-style browsing requires turning off scripting and style sheets, and although any intelligently
designed site should adapt to this, more and more sites just bail out if scripting is turned off. The new browser is welcome,
but it can't meet the expectations created by the new desktop view.
The BlackBerry 8800 integrates a feature that many mobile users don't realize they need: GPS. I was among those who saw GPS
as a gadget, and with respect to stand-alone GPS boxes that stick to the windshield, gadget is the right word. BlackBerry
8800's GPS receiver works in concert with its EDGE mobile network radio to provide real-time, turn-by-turn navigation on the
same handset that you use for phone calls and e-mail.
BlackBerry Maps is bundled with the 8800. It presents simple, fast, and accurate real-time tracking of your position on an
easy-to-read 2D moving map. The trackball lets you explore around the map, snapping back to your GPS position ten seconds
after you stop moving it. If you don't do a lot of driving for business, BlackBerry Maps is as much mapping and trip routing
as you need.
BlackBerry 8800's killer application is TeleNav GPS Navigator. After a 14-day trial, this application will cost you as much
as $9.95 per month, but if you drive, it's worth it. TeleNav puts every stick-to-the-window stand-alone navigator to shame
with crystal-clear spoken directions that include street names and exit numbers, with automatic re-routing to navigate around
traffic jams. Integration with BlackBerry's address book lets you select a contact, click "Drive To," and be on your way.
I'm reviewing the TeleNav service separately, but having it on the BlackBerry 8800 has changed the way I travel.
The flagship BlackBerry handset is the best yet in all regards. No, it won't replace your notebook's browser, but the GPS,
battery life, and the greatly improved interface go a long way toward making up the difference.
Given its shape and core features, Nokia's E61i is bound to be compared to BlackBerry, but the E61i is very much its own,
quite exceptional handset. The E61i's 802.11b/g Wi-Fi, wireless network universality, market-leading "Web 2.0" browser for
Web apps, large display, two-week standby battery life, VPN, VoIP support, local and remote configurability, strong security,
and incomparably flexible programmability make the E61i my recommendation for workforce, team, workgroup, and fleet deployments
that leverage existing IT infrastructure and services.
You can add wireless to an existing solution using the technical resources you already have. You can dole out a batch of E61i
handsets, make no alterations to your back-end services, create some Java, Perl, Python, AJAX, or C++ code to run on the handsets,
and you've gone wireless in record time. If you want to do the whole UI in HTML and JavaScript and yet maintain off-line operability,
you can run your Web app on an HTTP server that runs locally on the E61i. (Executives who want to be fully plugged into a
wireless solution built around the E61i but who don't want to lug around a big handset, will find the phone-sized E65 identical
to E61i in functionality and price. The E65 will be reviewed here tomorrow.)
An especially noteworthy recent addition to the Series 60 3rd Edition platform is Open C, a set of libraries and headers that
offer an unexpectedly rich subset of POSIX (Portable Operating System Interface) functionality. With Open C, it's possible
to port some existing UNIX and Linux software to run on the E61i and other S60 3rd Edition handsets, as well as write new
code using the easy and widely accepted BSD Sockets networking API. Oracle developed a cut of its database using Open C, and
other projects including an Apache-based, handset-hosted HTTP server have emerged.
The E61i's OSS Web browser is grand, outdoing all other browsers in this review. It's made from the best stuff -- Apple's
open source Webkit -- but if you're hoping to sneer at Nokia for plagiarizing the Safari or iPhone browser, you're in for
a letdown. Nokia managed to nicely emulate a mouse-driven desktop browsing experience using only a five-button directional
pad. A picture-in-picture full page overview pops up during rapid scrolling to make points of interest easy to find with zero
rendering delay. The scale of text and images can be altered independently, an approach that's superior to zooming the entire
view. The user can turn off graphics loading entirely for instant page viewing, loading images for a single page on command.
Clicking on an image brings up a full-screen view of it, which can be zoomed, rotated, and saved to disk.
 |
| The Bottom Line |
AT&T 8525 (HTC Hermes) AT&T, att.com
|
Fair 6.3 |
 |
| criteria |
score |
weight |
| Extensibility |
7 |
20% |
 |
| Messaging |
6 |
20% |
 |
| Networking |
7 |
20% |
 |
| Usability |
5 |
20% |
 |
| Multimedia |
8 |
10% |
 |
| Value |
5 |
10% |
 |
|
 |
Cost: $599.99 retail; $349.99 with two-year AT&T contract
Platforms: Windows Mobile 5 Pocket PC Edition; Windows XP or Vista required for desktop sync
Bottom Line: The AT&T 8525 (HTC Hermes) is a fatter, faster version of the T-Mobile Wing, but in a silvertone case. The thumbwheel, macro-focus
camera, and infrared are nice touches, but the 8525 is an old-fashioned brick that's uncomfortable to hold. At present, AT&T
is still shipping the 8525 with Windows Mobile 5, and a promised update to Windows Mobile 6 Professional is not available.
|
 |
About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology
|
|
 |
| The Bottom Line |
BlackBerry 8300 (Curve) Research In Motion, blackberry.com
|
Good 7.4 |
 |
| criteria |
score |
weight |
| Extensibility |
7 |
20% |
 |
| Messaging |
9 |
20% |
 |
| Networking |
7 |
20% |
 |
| Usability |
7 |
20% |
 |
| Multimedia |
8 |
10% |
 |
| Value |
6 |
10% |
 |
|
 |
Cost: $539 unlocked; $199.99 with two-year AT&T contract (currently $0 with rebate on amazon.com)
Platforms: BlackBerry Desktop backup, restore, upload requires Windows; included Roxio Media Manager (Windows) converts video and audio
for playback; Mac OS X PDA sync and upload with PocketMac (free download from blackberry.com); device is programmable in Java
using free RIM-supported tools; optional BlackBerry Enterprise Server software links to existing messaging server
Bottom Line: BlackBerry 8300 (Curve) kicks off a new trend toward more relaxed, lifestyle-friendly devices for individuals. Curve is a
full BlackBerry with a QWERTY keyboard and trackball, but in a smaller, more shapely package with Bluetooth stereo audio,
a two-megapixel still camera with light, and Windows software for converting video and audio for playback on the device.
|
 |
About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology
|
|
 |
| The Bottom Line |
BlackBerry 8800 Research In Motion, blackberry.com
|
Very Good 8.0 |
 |
| criteria |
score |
weight |
| Extensibility |
7 |
20% |
 |
| Messaging |
10 |
20% |
 |
| Networking |
7 |
20% |
 |
| Usability |
8 |
20% |
 |
| Multimedia |
7 |
10% |
 |
| Value |
9 |
10% |
 |
|
 |
Cost: $549 to $599 unlocked; $299 to $349 with two-year contract
Platforms: BlackBerry Desktop backup, restore, upload requires Windows; Mac OS X PDA sync and upload with PocketMac (free download from
blackberry.com); device is programmable in Java using free RIM-supported tools; optional BlackBerry Enterprise Server software
links to existing messaging server
Bottom Line: The BlackBerry 8800 is already established as the flagship BlackBerry handset on GSM/GPRS/EDGE networks. This rich and easy-to-use
device stands apart for its trackball, comfortable shape, perfected keyboard, built-in GPS with standard navigation software,
and unparalleled battery life supporting 22 days standby on a single charge.
|
 |
About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology
|
|
 |
| The Bottom Line |
HTC Advantage X7501 HTC, htc.com
|
Very Good 8.4 |
 |
| criteria |
score |
weight |
| Extensibility |
8 |
20% |
 |
| Messaging |
8 |
20% |
 |
| Networking |
10 |
20% |
 |
| Usability |
9 |
20% |
 |
| Multimedia |
7 |
10% |
 |
| Value |
7 |
10% |
 |
|
 |
Cost: $899
Platforms: Windows Mobile 6 Professional; syncs with Windows Outlook (trial version included); C++ and .NET Compact Framework and Visual
Studio 2005 are used to develop custom apps
Bottom Line: Finally, a Windows Mobile device that almost makes you want to leave your notebook PC at home. The X7501 is an absolute beauty,
with a sharp five-inch display, a snap-on QWERTY keyboard, fast Wi-Fi, an 8GB microdrive, and video output. The X7501 is not
cheap, but it'll make you and everyone who sees you with it forget all about the iPhone.
|
 |
About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology
|
|