Free Newsletters
Technology & Business Daily

InfoWorld
Log-in | Register

Supreme Court favors Microsoft in AT&T case

The 7-to-1 ruling changes how the software industry looks at patent rights


The U.S. Supreme Court ruled on Monday that Microsoft is not liable for using patented AT&T technology in copies of Windows running on computers outside the United States.

The 7-to-1 ruling relieves the software giant from paying what could have been enormous damages and changes how the software industry looks at patent rights.

Microsoft has previously admitted to violating an AT&T patent for converting speech to computer code, which it incorporated into tens of millions of copies of its Windows OS. It settled with AT&T in the United States, but disputed that Windows software running on machines located overseas were covered by the patent.

In a statement, AT&T said it was disappointed with the ruling. "All U.S.-based sources of innovation -- including the software development community -- could benefit from patent laws that enable fair, appropriate protection and valuation of new technologies and inventions domestically and overseas," the company said.

At issue was part of a 1984 patent law, Section 271F, which prevents companies from shipping parts overseas to be assembled in a fashion that would infringe on a U.S. patent.

Microsoft argued in front of the court in February that the master copies of Windows it ships overseas to other manufacturers are blueprints that do not violate patent laws.

AT&T, which filed the original case in federal court in New York in 2001, countered that Microsoft used the code in combination with other components in order to reap royalties from every copy of Windows sold.

AT&T had also argued that Section 271F created a loophole for software makers to avoid patent infringement by allowing installation copies to be mass-copied overseas.

In delivering the court's opinion, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote that the "master disk" or "electronic transmission" Microsoft gives to foreign manufacturers does not violate the patent on its own since that specific copy is not used on foreign-made computers.

"Instead, copies made abroad are used for installation," Ginsburg wrote. Because those copies are not supplied by Microsoft, the company does not supply the "components," she wrote.

A decision in favor of AT&T had could have put the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office into a role of an arbiter of intellectual property worldwide and pushed software prices higher.

The Supreme Court was the last stop for Microsoft, which had lost a previous court battle. In July 2005, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit upheld a lower-court ruling that Microsoft was liable to pay fines for foreign sales of patent-infringing software even if it was originally created in the United States.

But Microsoft had gained broad support in its defense efforts, including the Bush administration and tech giants Amazon.com, Intel, and Yahoo, and industry groups such as the Business Software Alliance and the American Intellectual Property Law Association.

AT&T was unavailable to comment.

This story was updated on April 30, 2007


Talkback:

commentPost a Comment

 

MOST COMMENTS

 
 





Virtualization: A Step by Step Approach to Success
Your virtual machines can be up and running in a matter of minutes. HP and Citrix have integrated XenServer with HP ProLiant servers and management tools, powered by hardware-assisted Intel Virtualization Technology to enable high- performance, cost-savings solutions for server consolidation and disaster recovery. Sponsor: HP

»  Click here to view this Webcast
  Storage is big, and getting bigger
The only certainty is that your requirement for storage will never be satisfied. While you clean out space and authorize POs, you might consider another alternative: outsourcing. The best way to deal with storage might be to let someone else deal with it. Sponsored by SGI

»  Click here to download now

- Special Advertising Partners -
WHITE PAPERS
 

» Technology White Papers Library

Technology White Papers by Topic

Technology White Papers E-mail Alert

Find out when the latest white paper is available:
 
 
INFOWORLD MARKETPLACE
 
» BUY A LINK NOW
 
 

Video

 
 
 

Podcasts

 
 
 

 

Columnists

 
 
 

Resource Center


Ads by techwords beta  [See your link here]
 




Sponsored Technology Links

 
 
 HOME  NEWS  BLOGS  PODCASTS  VIDEOS  TECHNOLOGIES  TEST CENTER  EVENTS  CAREERS  IT EXEC-CONNECT   About | Advertise | Awards | RSS | Contact Us 

Copyright © 2008, Reprints, Permissions, Licensing, IDG Network, Privacy Policy, Terms of Service.
All Rights reserved. InfoWorld is a leading publisher of technology information and product reviews on topics including viruses,
phishing, worms, firewalls, security, servers, storage, networking, wireless, databases, and web services.

CIO :: ComputerWorld :: CSO :: Demo :: GamePro :: Games.net :: IDG Connect :: IDG World Expo
Industry Standard :: IT World :: JavaWorld :: LinuxWorld :: MacUser :: Macworld :: Network World :: PC World :: Playlist