Free Newsletters
Technology & Business Daily

InfoWorld
Log-in | Register

Check Point and Sygate corral end points

Similarly strong network access control solutions make for a hard choice

By Victor R. Garza
December 05, 2005
 

At their core, Check Point Integrity and Sygate Enterprise Protection are effectively policy-based firewalls. That’s the cake. The icing is their capability to monitor other applications for compliance with configuration requirements and send errant machines to quarantine until they can be updated with the latest anti-virus definitions, Windows patches, or other necessities.

Free IT resource

Virtualization Insights from Top Experts - Learn how virtualization gets real!

Sponsored by Dell

Free IT resource

TechNet: More ways to know it, share it, and keep it running.

Sponsored by Microsoft

Both solutions rely on an end-point client closely coupled to a policy-management server, supporting a variety of mechanisms for quarantining noncompliant systems, including 802.1x authentication and integration with partner switches, routers, wireless APs, and VPNs.

Combining strong client security and flexible policy management, both Check Point Integrity 6.0 and Sygate Enterprise Protection 5.0 help prevent spyware, worms, trojans, and viruses from getting to the enterprise network from infected clients. In addition to ensuring that end points are secure and updated, both products can enforce policies governing which client-side applications can access the network based on almost any criteria you might want to apply.

Twin Towers of Access Control

Sygate’s Policy Manager has policy templates for common security patch deployments, personal firewalls, and anti-virus and anti-spyware software to help ease deployment. Depending on what type of adapter is being used to connect to the network (Ethernet, Wi-Fi, VPN, or the like) Sygate can apply appropriately restrictive access controls.

Between the Sygate Enforcement Agent (SEA) and the company network is the Enforcer, which applies access controls that the Policy Manager lays down. Noncompliant systems are placed into a quarantined network segment, where they can download the software needed to meet security requirements.

The SEA performs policy compliance checks during the initial connection and periodically via a timer or during a change in network location. Additionally, the SEA enforces policies when disconnected from the enterprise network, and it will automatically connect to your remediation download site to bring itself into compliance with or without user intervention.

For enforcing security policies on unmanaged end points, Sygate provides the ODA (On-Demand Agent). A Java applet that is downloaded to the client upon connection, ODA creates an encrypted virtual desktop with updated anti-virus software, anti-virus definitions, an anti-keystroke logger, and a personal firewall. After the session, ODA deletes all traces and removes itself from the system.

Check Point Integrity provides much of the same functionality. Instead of providing an enforcement gateway of its own, however, Integrity works with Check Point’s VPN-1, Connectra SSL VPN, and InterSpect IPS, as well as 802.1x-enabled gear, to quarantine noncompliant clients. Integrity works with switches from Cisco Systems, Enterasys, Extreme Networks, Foundry, HP, and other vendors, and counts Aventail, Cisco, Juniper, Microsoft, and Nortel among its SSL VPN partners. Sygate has partners of its own, including many of the same names, and its Enforcer gives customers who may not have an 802.1x infrastructure the option of implementing NAC without buying additional gear.

Like the Sygate agent, Integrity Client checks for compliance upon connection and during sessions, and it provides self-enforcement and auto-remediation capabilities. Check Point also provides an on-demand client, called Integrity Clientless Security, which uses ActiveX to deploy the Integrity Secure Browser to unmanaged systems. The Secure Browser creates a captive portal via connection to a Check Point or partner SSL VPN, also encrypting session data, blocking browser-cache copying and keystroke logging, and removing all traces when the session is terminated.


Continued
1 | 2 | 3 | Next Page » 



Check Point Integrity 6.0

Check Point Software, checkpoint.com

Very Good  8.1
criteria score weight
Management 8 20%
Scalability 9 20%
Security 8 20%
Reporting 8 15%
Setup 7 15%
Value 8 10%

Cost:
Below $40 to $60 per client seat, depending on volume

Platforms:
Integrity Server: Integrity Server: Windows 2000 Server, Windows Server 2003, Red Hat Enterprise Linux ES 3.0; Integrity Client: Windows 2000 Pro, XP Pro, Red Hat Enterprise Linux WS 3.0

Bottom Line:
This version of Integrity shows that a great deal of effort went into making the product a good fit for the security-minded enterprise. Leveraging strong client security with the Zone Labs pedigree, plus solid management and reporting capabilities, Integrity is a strong contender for end-point security and policy-based network access control.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology



Sygate Enterprise Protection 5.0

Sygate, sygate.com

Very Good  8.3
criteria score weight
Management 8 20%
Scalability 9 20%
Security 9 20%
Reporting 8 15%
Setup 7 15%
Value 8 10%

Cost:
$20 to $80 per client seat, depending on volume

Platforms:
Policy Manager: Windows Server 2003; Database: Microsoft SQL Server 2000 or Integrated Database; Enforcer: Red Hat Enterprise Linux; Enforcement Agent: Windows 2000, Windows Server 2003, Windows XP Pro

Bottom Line:
Sygate has been monitoring enterprise clients for security and operational compliance for many years, and it shows. Solid policy management and reporting capabilities make this a stand-out solution. New peripheral compliance management brings the use of USB storage and other peripheral devices under administrative control.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology



 


 
Victor R. Garza is a senior contributing editor at InfoWorld.

  Victor R. Garza's Weblog


 

TOP NEWS:


»  Intel says Moblin update coming soon
Open-source effort set for mobile Linux should have an alpha-level release in a few weeks

»  Are virtual firewalls a solution for VM security?
Virtual firewalls can be a useful security tool, but their efficacy depends heavily on how you have set up your networks

»  Ubuntu to unveil new version of Launchpad next week
Ubuntu's beta community still has a long way to go to achieve the popularity of competitors such as SourceForge.net

»  Oracle unveils access management suite
Oracle's suite includes a new server that provides controls to fine-tune user privileges

»  5 ways the iPhone 3G still lags in enterprise
Despite Apple's improvements, its iPhone 2.0 software remain less competent and less tested than its BlackBerry and Windows Mobile counterparts

»  Ubuntu founder urges Linux desktop to rival Apple
Shuttleworth also cites need for new business models to fund free software




TAKE CONTROL OF YOUR CONTENT- LEVERAGE MICROSOFT SHAREPOINT
Microsoft Office SharePoint Server (MOSS) offers core content management designed for a broad user population. Attend this webcast to learn how to implement a strategy that allows for the coexistence of both MOSS and advanced ECM solution within the same IT environment. Sponsor: IBM

»  Click here to view this Webcast
  Zombie PCs Are Attacking Your LAN
A recent study showed that malware-infected zombie PCs are now a bigger threat to ISPs and Web infrastructure than DoS attacks. As this brand new IT Strategy Guide explains, an increased use of peer-to-peer techniques by the attackers has made it harder to fight back. Download now, compliments of Verio:

»  Click here to download now

- Special Advertising Partners -
WHITE PAPERS
 

» Technology White Papers Library

Technology White Papers by Topic

Technology White Papers E-mail Alert

Find out when the latest white paper is available:
 
 
INFOWORLD MARKETPLACE
 
» BUY A LINK NOW
 

FIND PRODUCTS AND COMPANIES
» COMPLETE PRODUCT GUIDE



TECHNOLOGY INDEX
• Applications
• Application Development
• Security
• Networking
• Wireless
• Platforms
• Hardware
• Data Management
• Storage
• Web Services
• Business
• Telecom
• Professional Services
• Standards

TECH WATCH 


What's the 411 on GOOG-411?
Just as Google has become synonymous with "performing a Web search," 411 is understood to mean "information" -- as in "what's the 411?" I was thus surprised to discover, from a billboard, no less, that the king of search is taking on the ...

Apple HTML source reveals 'iPhone Extreme'
"This one's a stretch..." reports AppleInsider. Um, yeah. Reporting on HTML code sightings of product names could be called a stretch, but iPhone Extreme has a ring to it. Now, that sounds like the product Apple should have released first, rather ...

COLUMNISTS

Unified under law
Ephraim Schwartz's Column and Blog (InfoWorld) - In the litigious world we live in, deploying a unified communications platform in your enterprise could...
» MORE COLUMNISTS

MORE INFOWORLD BLOGS


Open Sources 
Product Management
When I joined MySQL four years ago, there was quite a lot of debate about product management. We didn't actually have ...

Zero Day 
Botnet herders tending smaller flocks
New research backs up the theory that botnet operators are keeping their networks smaller in a continued effort to keep ...



• Advice Line
• Database Underground
• The Deep End
• Enterprise Mac
• Geeks in Paradise
• Grid Meter
• The Gripe Line
• InfoWorld Daily
• Inside IT
• IT Troubleshooter
• ITXtreme
• Open Sources
• ProdBlog
• Real World SOA
• Reality Check
• Security Adviser
• SMB IT
• The Storage Network
• Tech Watch
• Virtualization Report
• Zero Day

ADVERTISEMENT


RESOURCE CENTERadvertisement 

GOVERNMENT IT & POLICY
'If you don't go after the network, you're never going to stop these guys. Never.'
From the State Department, All the News for Inquiring Minds
TechPresident, the Internet Citizenry's New Consensus Taker



Sponsored Technology Links

 
 
 HOME  NEWS  BLOGS  PODCASTS  VIDEOS  TECHNOLOGIES  TEST CENTER  EVENTS  CAREERS   About | Advertise | Awards | RSS | Contact Us 

Copyright © 2008, Reprints, Permissions, Licensing, IDG Network, Privacy Policy, Terms of Service.
All Rights reserved. InfoWorld is a leading publisher of technology information and product reviews on topics including viruses,
phishing, worms, firewalls, security, servers, storage, networking, wireless, databases, and web services.

CIO :: ComputerWorld :: CSO :: Demo :: GamePro :: Games.net :: IDG Connect :: IDG World Expo
Industry Standard :: IT World :: JavaWorld :: LinuxWorld :: MacUser :: Macworld :: Network World :: PC World :: Playlist