This limitation aside, Breeze is a showcase for Macromedia’s Flash technology, which drives the presenter and attendee UI.
Presenters access various Pods (palettes), which have been prearranged for sharing, discussion, or collaboration. For example,
the sharing arrangement includes Pods for video, attendees, chat, and notes, and they are neatly clustered around the main
presentation stage.
In addition to creating a pleasing appearance, Macromedia clearly seeks to enhance usability in Breeze 5. During PowerPoint
presentations, a sidebar allowed me to quickly scan through thumbnails of slides and perform full-text search of slide content.
Controls for other basic tasks, such as drawing annotations, are now placed where you’d expect them to be -- within the presentation
frame.
A more significant change permits asynchronous content such as a recorded Breeze presentation with audio to be played within
a live meeting. For hosts who aren’t familiar with a niche topic, this allows them to retrieve a multimedia presentation from
the library and effortlessly include it in their overall meeting.
Pod management has been streamlined in Version 5. Each Pod includes a clearly marked pop-up menu capable of grouping relevant
options. This functionality makes it much easier to change participant rights, including an attendee’s role or Pod access.
In keeping with a main industry trend, Breeze 5 boosts audio support. Breeze’s VoIP setup wizard optimizes settings, including
sensing background noise so that you can hear users only when they speak. I controlled audio-conferencing functions from the
unified Breeze audio interface, including calling participants.
Another previously weaker area, Q&A sessions, is now far less disruptive. As presenter, I revealed a Q&A Pod that collected
questions from a chat Pod. I then answered these queries as time permitted -- both publicly and privately -- and forwarded
a few to another presenter. In the past, presenters had to pay attention to their main content while monitoring real-time
chat.
In a similar way, Breeze 5 allowed me to perform “behind-the-scenes” content preparation and layout customization during a
meeting, which I then showed to the live audience when all was ready.
The hallmark presentation part of this product, Breeze Presenter, remains strong. I quickly edited audio that accompanied
PowerPoint presentations. Moreover, Breeze provides four new question types -- fill-in-the-blank, rating scale, matching,
and short answer -- and question branching. Plus, quiz feedback can now be provided using audio and video. These capabilities
form the foundation of the training module, and trainers can now use a wizard for creating progressive learning tracks. I
built a custom program that blended self-paced courses and live training. It is also easy to assign prerequisites, scoring,
and completion requirements and to view reports that show employee participation.
Breeze also maintains its Web Services Framework. For this test, I used the software’s XML output to build a personalized
course list that appeared in a Microsoft SharePoint portal.
Finally, Breeze Events is a new application for managing large meetings. I created custom online self-registration forms and
was able to track responses, authorize participation, and create post-event follow-up e-mails.

Macromedia Breeze Meeting Central 5
Macromedia, macromedia.com
|
Excellent 8.7 |
 |
| criteria |
score |
weight |
| Features |
9 |
30% |
 |
| Ease-of-use |
9 |
20% |
 |
| Integration |
9 |
20% |
 |
| Performance |
8 |
20% |
 |
| Value |
8 |
10% |
 |
|
 |
Cost: Hosted service, from 32 cents per minute, per user; in-house software, starts at
$10,000
Platforms: ASP model; installed application requires Microsoft Windows 2000 or 2003 Server
Bottom Line: With Breeze 5, users can collaborate through Web meetings, manage large events, deliver on-demand PowerPoint presentations
with audio, and build online training systems complete with course and content management. Its simple UI makes for easy meeting
participation, plus meeting hosts will enjoy the broad customization options. Based on Flash, Breeze 5 works without limitation
on numerous platforms.
|
 |
About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology
|
|

Microsoft Office Live Meeting 2005
Microsoft, microsoft.com
|
Very Good 8.5 |
 |
| criteria |
score |
weight |
| Features |
8 |
30% |
 |
| Ease-of-use |
9 |
20% |
 |
| Integration |
8 |
20% |
 |
| Performance |
9 |
20% |
 |
| Value |
9 |
10% |
 |
|
 |
Cost: Standard Edition, starts at 35 cents per minute (plus $3,000 setup) for monthly minutes; Professional Edition, starts at $30,000
per year (plus $3,000 setup) for unlimited meetings
Platforms: Hosted remotely; Windows, Mac OS 10.3, Solaris 9 (with reduced functionality)
Bottom Line: Not only does this Microsoft-centric Web conferencing service allow small teams to work together and organizations to provide
training, it also scales easily to handle online events for thousands of attendees. New features simplify the scheduling of
meetings. Integrated VoIP audio broadcasting, simplified presentation controls, and expanded localized versions make it suitable
for both regional and global enterprises.
|
 |
About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology
|
|

WebEx Meeting Center 7
WebEx Communications, webex.com
|
Excellent 8.8 |
 |
| criteria |
score |
weight |
| Features |
9 |
30% |
 |
| Ease-of-use |
8 |
20% |
 |
| Integration |
9 |
20% |
 |
| Performance |
9 |
20% |
 |
| Value |
9 |
10% |
 |
|
 |
Cost: Named user, starting at $75 a month for meetings with as many as 15 people, unlimited use (no annual fee); concurrent user,
starting at $100 a month, unlimited use (no annual fee); per-minute pricing, starts at 30 cents
Platforms: Remotely hosted; option for premises-based node
Bottom Line: WebEx’s third-generation collaboration application is tailored to specific needs, and its streamlined interface provides for
an excellent Web meeting experience. Beyond professional, multimedia presentations, the improved MediaTone backbone network
offers toll-free audioconferencing in 30 countries. MediaTone APIs integrate WebEx applications into CRM, call center, and
e-learning systems.
|
 |
About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology
|
|