Free Newsletters
InfoWorld Daily

  
InfoWorld
Log-in | Register
Username:   Password:   forgot password?
Logged in as | Log-out

How the portals scored

Find the ratings for the seven portals in our tests


April 30, 2004
 
E-mailE-mail  print thisPrinter Friendly  reprintsReprints  Slashdot Slashdot It!





BEA WebLogic Platform 8.1

BEA Systems, bea.com

Very Good  8.1
criteria score weight
Ease-of-use 8 25%
Integration 8 25%
Implementation 9 20%
Manageability 8 20%
Value 7 10%

Cost:
$57,000 per CPU (includes WebLogic Portal, WebLogic Server, WebLogic Workshop); $90,000 per CPU (adds WebLogic Integration)

Platforms:
HP-UX, IBM AIX, Red Hat Linux, Sun Solaris, Windows 2000

Bottom Line:
BEA WebLogic Platform 8.1, which includes WebLogic Portal 8.1, provides a total solution for creating custom portals. The unified infrastructure lets developers work with BEA WebLogic Workshop 8.1 for advanced portal and portlet creation, and general portal administration can be distributed to others. The product’s strong developer tools and life-cycle application management stand out.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology



IBM WebSphere Portal for Multiplatforms Version 5.0

IBM, ibm.com

Very Good  7.6
criteria score weight
Ease-of-use 7 25%
Integration 8 25%
Implementation 8 20%
Manageability 8 20%
Value 6 10%

Cost:
$87,000 per processor for Portal Extend; Portal Express starst at $85 per user or $33,000 per processor

Platforms:
Windows 2000 Server, Linux on Intel (Red Hat, SuSE), AIX, Solaris 8, and SuSE Linux Enterprise Server 7 for IBM zSeries

Bottom Line:
WebSphere Portal 5.0 integrated disparate corporate apps and information, giving users a personalized view of data required for their jobs. Employees can colalborate in real-time, as well as create, publish, search and share information, though inline document editing could be improved. Portlet builders and a large catalog of third-party portlets significantly reduce development time.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology



SharePoint Portal Server 2003

Microsoft, microsoft.com

Very Good  7.9
criteria score weight
Ease-of-use 9 25%
Integration 7 25%
Implementation 8 20%
Manageability 8 20%
Value 7 10%

Cost:
SharePoint Portal Server, $3,999, plus $71 per client license

Platforms:
Windows Server 2003

Bottom Line:
SharePoint Portal Server 2003 focuses on information and document sharing, making it a top choice for team collaboration. It is easy to set up and customize, although the maximum benefit comes when coupled with Microsoft Office 2003 and Microsoft back-office applications.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology



OracleAS Portal 10g

Oracle, oracle.com

Very Good  7.8
criteria score weight
Ease-of-use 7 25%
Integration 8 25%
Implementation 8 20%
Manageability 8 20%
Value 8 10%

Cost:
Standard Edition, $10,000 per CPU or $200 per user; Enterprise Edition, $20,000 per CPU or $400 per user

Platforms:
Sun Solaris, HP-UX, HP Tru64 UNIX, Red Hat Linux, SuSE Linux, UnitedLinux, Windows 2000 Server, IBM AIX

Bottom Line:
OracleAS Portal 10g, a component of the Oracle Application Server 10g distribution, is an inclusive solution for creating a portal Web interface, publishing information, and delivering personalized content to users. Less technical users can perform the bulk of setup and administration so developers can concentrate on J2EE portlet application work.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology



Plumtree Enterprise Web Suite

Plumtree, plumtree.com

Excellent  8.7
criteria score weight
Ease-of-use 9 25%
Integration 9 25%
Implementation 8 20%
Manageability 9 20%
Value 8 10%

Cost:
Complete suite, including startup professional services and training: $125,000 for 250 users

Platforms:
Windows 2000; Oracle 9i or Microsoft SQL 2000 databases; BEA WebLogic 7.0, IBM WebSphere 4.0, or JBoss 3.0.4 with Tomcat 4.0.6

Bottom Line:
Plumtree Enterprise Web Suite’s Portal 5.0, Collaboration, Content and Studio servers work together seamlessly, giving users a fine portal experience. What’s more, Plumtree provides centralized security and administration of Web applications on different systems -- both within and outside the enterprise -- in one portal environment. This outstanding approach to Web application deployment yields simple operation for users along with lower development and maintenance costs for an organization.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology



Java System Portal Server 6.2

Sun Microsystems, sun.com

Very Good  8.1
criteria score weight
Ease-of-use 7 25%
Integration 8 25%
Implementation 9 20%
Manageability 8 20%
Value 9 10%

Cost:
$57,000 to $95,000 per CPU, per application server or $100 per employee for entire enterprise suite

Platforms:
OS: Solaris, Windows, Linux available Spring 2004; Application Server: BEA WebLogic, IBM WebSphere, Sun

Bottom Line:
Sun’s portal, based on Java Web services, is a top-to-bottom solution that includes identity, application, directory, and Web servers. It’s one of the more developer-friendly portals -- especially for mobile devices, JSR 168 portlets, and Web services -- and has unique VPN-on-Demand with secure remote access.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology



Vignette Application Portal 7.0

Vignette, vignette.com

Very Good  8.2
criteria score weight
Ease-of-use 8 25%
Integration 8 25%
Implementation 9 20%
Manageability 8 20%
Value 8 10%

Cost:
Starts at $75,000 per CPU (per user pricing available upon request)

Platforms:
OS: IBM AIX, Red Hat Linux, Sun Solaris, Windows 2000; Database: IBM DB2, Oracle, Microsoft SQL, Sybase; Application Server: IBM WebSphere, Apache Tomcat, BEA WebLogic, Sun ONE

Bottom Line:
Using supplied portlets, Vignette Application Portal lets you create an initial portal site and rapidly tie in enterprise applications using industry-standard portlet programming interfaces. The system’s strong administration and internalization -- plus broad platform support -- can reduce TCO when deploying multiple portals.

About our Reviews and Scoring Methodology



 
E-mailE-mail  print thisPrinter Friendly  reprintsReprints  Slashdot Slashdot It!

TOP NEWS:


»  Four quick tips for choosing an IM security product
71 percent of businesses will invest in real-time messaging this year. If you're one of them, be sure to protect your enterprise

»  Forrester analysts ID hot IT jobs
Research group finds 16 IT roles with a promising future

»  Nvidia claims 10 hours of HD video on Tegra chip
The Tegra 600 and 650 can be used with hard disk drives and are designed partly for mobile Internet devices

»  Database vendors add Google's MapReduce
Greenplum and Aster Data Systems will support Google's programming technique, developed for parallel processing of large data sets across commodity hardware

»  Network management: Tips for managing costs
New technologies, changing requirements, and ongoing equipment maintenance and upgrades cost money, but there are ways to manage expenses

»  EMC targets SMBs, branch offices with new low-end storage
Celerra NX4 highlights include thin provisioning, snapshot technology for data recovery and backups, and Web-based console for management of storage volumes




REMOTE ACCESS: MAINTAIN SECURITY AND DECREASE THE BURDEN ON IT
Join this interactive webcast to discover how IT Managers can control access rights, end-user security settings and end-point authorization. Sponsor: Citrix(R) GoToMyPC(R) Corporate

»  Click here to view this Webcast
  WAN Emulation Sponsored Solutions Guide
WAN emulation technology enables IT organizations to predict reliably how applications will perform in a networked environment, before application rollout, mitigating development risk and costs.This Sponsores Solutions Guide has everything you need to now about WAN emulation and WAN and how to best implement it in your organization. Sponsored by Shunra

»  Click here to download now

- Special Advertising Partners -
WHITE PAPERS
 
  • Securing the Converged Enterprise II - Securing the converged enterprise has become a multidimensional discipline requiring a centralized, defense-in-depth approach...
  • Nucleus Report: Who's ready for SMB? - With Oracle and SAP ramping up their efforts to attract midsize businesses to their enterprise applications, many have ...
  • Symantec(TM) Network Access Control: Comprehensive Network Access Control - This white paper discusses the challenges involved with endpoint policy compliance and how organizations can leverage Symantec...
  • New CLARiiON CX4 Doubles Performance, Scale, and Connectivity - "Bigger better faster" is what everyone expects from a storage platform upgrade, and EMC does not disappoint with the CX4...
  • Automating Data Flows to Your Business Intelligence System - Business Intelligence, (BI), is an amazing value to your business, but it could be even better if you improve upon the way...
  • Your Guide to Troubleshooting Application Problems - This guide covers the fundamentals of how applications work and flow, where applications fail and best practices for troubleshooting...

» Technology White Papers Library

Technology White Papers by Topic

Technology White Papers E-mail Alert

    • »  Application development
    • »  Applications
    • »  Business
    • »  Data Protection
    • »  Data management
    • »  Hardware
    • »  Networking
    • »  Platforms
    • »  Professional services
    • »  SOA
    • »  Security
    • »  Storage
    • »  Virtualization
Find out when the latest white paper is available:
 
 
INFOWORLD MARKETPLACE
 
  • Deliver REMOTE SUPPORT Easily. Try WebEx FREE! - DOWNLOAD WEBEX SUPPORT CENTER FREE! Deliver efficient, effective support. CRUSH SUPPORT LOG JAMS!
  • Migrating to an IP-VPN? XO Can Make It Happen - Learn the five critical success factors with a free whitepaper from XO Enterprise Solutions.
  • Sign up to TRY WEBEX SUPPORT CENTER FOR FREE! - Get your FULL FEATURED trial here. Share documents and applications, address support challenges.
  • IP Networks Boost Secure Health Communications - AT&T provides secure communication to keep health care moving forward.
  • Why a CMDB? - IT best practices (ITIL) have shown the benefits of a CMDB. Click for whitepapers.
» BUY A LINK NOW
 

FIND PRODUCTS AND COMPANIES
» COMPLETE PRODUCT GUIDE



TECHNOLOGY INDEX
• Applications
• Application Development
• Security
• Networking
• Wireless
• Platforms
• Hardware
• Data Management
• Storage
• Web Services
• Business
• Telecom
• Professional Services
• Standards

TECH WATCH 


What's the 411 on GOOG-411?
Just as Google has become synonymous with "performing a Web search," 411 is understood to mean "information" -- as in "what's the 411?" I was thus surprised to discover, from a billboard, no less, that the king of search is taking on the ...

Apple HTML source reveals 'iPhone Extreme'
"This one's a stretch..." reports AppleInsider. Um, yeah. Reporting on HTML code sightings of product names could be called a stretch, but iPhone Extreme has a ring to it. Now, that sounds like the product Apple should have released first, rather ...

COLUMNISTS

Unified under law
Ephraim Schwartz's Column and Blog (InfoWorld) - In the litigious world we live in, deploying a unified communications platform in your enterprise could...
» MORE COLUMNISTS

MORE INFOWORLD BLOGS


Open Sources 
Product Management
When I joined MySQL four years ago, there was quite a lot of debate about product management. We didn't actually have ...

Zero Day 
Botnet herders tending smaller flocks
New research backs up the theory that botnet operators are keeping their networks smaller in a continued effort to keep ...



• Advice Line
• Database Underground
• The Deep End
• Enterprise Mac
• Geeks in Paradise
• Grid Meter
• The Gripe Line
• InfoWorld Daily
• Inside IT
• IT Troubleshooter
• ITXtreme
• Open Sources
• ProdBlog
• Real World SOA
• Reality Check
• Security Adviser
• SMB IT
• The Storage Network
• Tech Watch
• Virtualization Report
• Zero Day

ADVERTISEMENT


RESOURCE CENTERadvertisement 

Ads by techwords beta


See your link here


GOVERNMENT IT & POLICY
• 'If you don't go after the network, you're never going to stop these guys. Never.'
• From the State Department, All the News for Inquiring Minds
• TechPresident, the Internet Citizenry's New Consensus Taker



Sponsored Technology Links

 
  • Fluke - Your Guide to Troubleshooting Application Problems
  • Nortel - Nortel data networks can save you up to 40% on energy costs.
  • Microsoft - Learn about the software-based VoIP solution from Microsoft.
  • Xerox - Print for pennies per page with Xerox color! Click to learn more.
  • AT&T - Machines That Speak: The Machine-to-Machine Wireless Network
  • AT&T - AT&T Article: Reinventing the Telephone with VoIP
  • AT&T - New from AT&T: Discover Fixed-Mobile Convergence Now
  • AT&T - AT&T Business Continuity Survey on Risk Management
  • AT&T - The Top 10 Best Practices for Server Virtualization Planning
  • AT&T - Securing the Converged Enterprise I
  • AT&T - Securing the Converged Enterprise II
  • AT&T - An AT&T White Paper: Enterprise IPTV Solution
  • AT&T - An AT&T Article: When Content is King
  • Villanova University - Prepare for CISSP(R) or CompTIA(R) Certification - 100% Online!
  • AT&T - Maximizing Mobility in Communications
  • AT&T - The Spirit of Innovation: 100 IT Leaders Speak Out
  • CA - Manage your IT more effectively.
  • InterSystems - Use Ensemble - quickly create composite applications.
  • Intel - Processor-enabled Virtualization. That's IT as it should be.
  • CA - Plan IT better, Manage IT better.
  • Rackspace - Rackspace: The True Value of a Hosting Provider
  • AMD - The Future is Fusion. Only from AMD. Learn more.
  • Symantec - Symantec(TM) Network Access Control: Comprehensive Network Access Control
  • Oracle - Nucleus Report: Who's ready for SMB?
  • Symantec - Enterprise-class Disaster Recovery for Virtual Server Environments
 
  • Adobe - Delivering On The Promise Of eLearning
  • Active Endpoints - Get ActiveVOS. Design, develop, deploy, manage services-based apps.
  • Eaton - Distributing Power to Blade Servers
  • Radware - Business-Smart Automation for Optimizing Your Virtualized Data Center
  • HP - Secure your network with HP's thin client computers.
  • AppAssure - 3 Best Practices for Reducing Exchange Downtime
  • Electric Cloud - Agile Development: 5 Steps to Continuous Integration
  • Oracle - Best Practices for Successful SOA Governance
  • MKS - Get Power and Simplicity of UNIX while working in Windows
  • HP - HP Color LaserJet CP4005n printer. Now $899. SHOP NOW
  • Dell - Dell Latitude: Battery life up to 19 hours. Learn more.
  • Equallogic - Flexible, Scalable, Enterprise Storage for Virtual Infrastructures
  • Equallogic - Four Steps to Disaster Recovery and Business Continuity Using iSCSI
  • HP - Get Extreme Storage for Extreme Business with HP.
  • Dell/Equallogic - PS Series Best Practices Deploying Microsoft(R) Exchange Server 2007 in an iSCSI SAN
  • Dell - Windows Vista: A Cyber Security Shield
  • HP - HP LaserJet P4014n printer Starting at $699 after $100 IS. SHOP NOW
  • HP - HP LaserJet M3035 MFP series Starting at $1,599. SHOP NOW
  • HP - HP StorageWorks products-control, consolidation and confidence.
  • Platespin - Consolidated Disaster Recovery Using Virtualization
  • Platespin - 8 Phases of a Successful Consolidation Initiative
  • AMD - Renowned Engineering Institution Chooses AMD Processor-Based Servers
  • AMD - Watch this flash demo of the Quad-Core AMD Opteron Processor
  • AMD - HP and Oracle deploy unbreakable computing infrastructure
  • Qwest - Learn how Qwest voice and data solutions can save you time.
 HOME  NEWS  BLOGS  PODCASTS  VIDEOS  TECHNOLOGIES  TEST CENTER  EVENTS  CAREERS   About | Advertise | Awards | RSS | Contact Us 

Copyright © 2008, Reprints, Permissions, Licensing, IDG Network, Privacy Policy, Terms of Service.
All Rights reserved. InfoWorld is a leading publisher of technology information and product reviews on topics including viruses,
phishing, worms, firewalls, security, servers, storage, networking, wireless, databases, and web services.

CIO :: ComputerWorld :: CSO :: Demo :: GamePro :: Games.net :: IDG Connect :: IDG World Expo
Industry Standard :: IT World :: JavaWorld :: LinuxWorld :: MacUser :: Macworld :: Network World :: PC World :: Playlist